Estimating the effective population size across space and time in the Critically Endangered western chimpanzee in Guinea-Bissau: challenges and implications for conservation management

Abstract

Effective population size (Ne) is a key concept in evolutionary and conservation biology. The western chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes verus) is a Critically Endangered taxon. In Guinea-Bissau, chimpanzees are mainly threatened by habitat loss, hunting and diseases. Guinea-Bissau is considered a key area for its conservation. Genetic tools have not yet been applied to inform management and no estimates of Ne have been obtained. In this study, we use country s range-wide microsatellite data and five whole-genome sequences to estimate several Ne and infer the recent and ancient demographic history of populations using different methods. We also aim to integrate the different Ne estimates to improve our understanding of the evolutionary history and current demography of this great ape and to discuss strengths and limitations of each estimator and their complementarity in informing conservation decisions. Results from the PSMC method suggest a large ancestral Ne, likely due to ancient structure over the whole subspecies distribution until approximately 10-15,000 years ago. After that, a change in connectivity, a real decrease in size or a combination of both occurred, which reduced the then still large ancestral population to a smaller size (MSVAR: ~10,000 decreasing to 1,000-6,000 individuals), possibly indicating a fragmentation into coastal and inner subpopulations. In the most recent past, contemporary Ne is below or close to 500 (GONE: 116-580, NeEstimator: 107-549), suggesting a high risk of extinction. The populations at coastal Parks may have been small or isolated for several generations whereas the Boe Park one exhibit higher long-term Ne estimates and can be considered a stronghold of chimpanzee conservation. Through combining different types of molecular markers and analytical methodologies, we try to overcome the limitations of obtaining high quality DNA sampling from wild threatened populations and estimate Ne at different temporal and spatial scales, which is crucial information to make informed conservation decisions at local and regional scales.