Estimating the Health Effects of Adding Bicycle and Pedestrian Paths at the Census Tract Level: Multiple Model Comparison

Abstract

Background Adding additional bicycle and pedestrian paths to an area can lead to improved health outcomes for residents over time. However, quantitatively determining which areas benefit more from bicycle and pedestrian paths, how many miles of bicycle and pedestrian paths are needed, and the health outcomes that may be most improved remain open questions. Objective Our work provides and evaluates a methodology that offers actionable insight for city-level planners, public health officials, and decision makers tasked with the question “To what extent will adding specified bicycle and pedestrian path mileage to a census tract improve residents’ health outcomes over time?” Methods We conducted a factor analysis of data from the American Community Survey, Center for Disease Control 500 Cities project, Strava, and bicycle and pedestrian path location and use data from two different cities (Norfolk, Virginia, and San Francisco, California). We constructed 2 city-specific factor models and used an algorithm to predict the expected mean improvement that a specified number of bicycle and pedestrian path miles contributes to the identified health outcomes. Results We show that given a factor model constructed from data from 2011 to 2015, the number of additional bicycle and pedestrian path miles in 2016, and a specific census tract, our models forecast health outcome improvements in 2020 more accurately than 2 alternative approaches for both Norfolk, Virginia, and San Francisco, California. Furthermore, for each city, we show that the additional accuracy is a statistically significant improvement (P<.001 in every case) when compared with the alternate approaches. For Norfolk, Virginia (n=31 census tracts), our approach estimated, on average, the percentage of individuals with high blood pressure in the census tract within 1.49% (SD 0.85%), the percentage of individuals with diabetes in the census tract within 1.63% (SD 0.59%), and the percentage of individuals who had >2 weeks of poor physical health days in the census tract within 1.83% (SD 0.57%). For San Francisco (n=49 census tracts), our approach estimates, on average, that the percentage of individuals who had a stroke in the census tract is within 1.81% (SD 0.52%), and the percentage of individuals with diabetes in the census tract is within 1.26% (SD 0.91%). Conclusions We propose and evaluate a methodology to enable decision makers to weigh the extent to which 2 bicycle and pedestrian paths of equal cost, which were proposed in different census tracts, improve residents’ health outcomes; identify areas where bicycle and pedestrian paths are unlikely to be effective interventions and other strategies should be used; and quantify the minimum amount of additional bicycle path miles needed to maximize health outcome improvements. Our methodology shows statistically significant improvements, compared with alternative approaches, in historical accuracy for 2 large cities (for 2016) within different geographic areas and with different demographics.

Measurement and Spatio-Temporal Characteristics of High-Quality Development Efficiency in Metropolitan Areas: A Case Study of the Changchun Metropolitan Area

“…The primary objective is to identify the underlying factors that can categorize variables with similar attributes, thereby reducing the complexity of the variables. Additionally, factor analysis allows for the testing of hypotheses pertaining to the relationships between variables [67,68].…”

Understanding and Assessing Demographic (In)Equity Resulting from Extreme Heat Exposure due to Lack of Tree Canopies in Norfolk, VA using Agent-Based Modeling

“…Understanding health benefits of biodiversity is paramount as research has shown that temperature decreases caused by tree canopies can statistically significantly decrease the number of deaths and doctor visits in an urban area, especially for those age 65 or greater [12,34]. Additional health and lifestyle improvements including high levels of physical exercise, mental well-being, and perceived safety have been linked at a fine-grained geographic level to extent of tree canopy coverage [35,36,37,38]. Furthermore, Li et al found that hospitals in redlined zones have more heat-related outpatient visits and high inpatient admission rates [39].…”

Empirical Study of ESG Score Prediction through Machine Learning—A Case of Non-Financial Companies in Taiwan

“…It utilizes the principle of ensemble learning, combining multiple decision trees to construct a more robust learning model, thus reducing the problem of overfitting and improving prediction accuracy as a machine learning method. Breiman defined RF as a set of tree-like structures forming a classifier, as shown in (9):…”

“…In the realm of water resource management, Koop et al [8] applied the geometric aggregation method to enhance the lowest-scoring indicators in integrated water resources management. In studies pertaining to public health, Gore, Ross, et al [9] and Zamponi, Virginia et al [10] employed statistical modeling techniques to assess various aspects of public health. Typically, rating agencies determine the ESG or sustainability scores based on the information disclosed by the companies themselves [11].…”