Ethical challenges in the COVID-19 research context: a toolkit for supporting analysis and resolution

Abstract

COVID-19 is compromising all aspects of society, with devastating impacts on health, political, social, economic and educational spheres. A premium is being placed on scientific research as the source of possible solutions, with a situational imperative to carry out investigations at an accelerated rate. There is a major challenge not to neglect ethical standards, in a context where doing so may mean the difference between life and death. In this paper we offer a rubric for considering the ethical challenges in COVID-19 related research, in the form of an ethics toolkit for global research developed at the University of Edinburgh in collaboration with more than 200 global researchers from around the world. This toolkit provides a framework to support confrontation of ethical conflicts through the integrated and iterative analysis of Place, People, Principles and Precedents, throughout the research journey. Two case analyses are offered to exemplify the utility of the toolkit as a flexible and dynamic tool to promote ethical research in the context of COVID-19.

NOTICE OF RETRACTION: The Influence of Ethical and Transformational Leadership on Employee Creativity in Malaysia's Private Higher Education Institutions: The Mediating Role of Organizational Citizenship Behaviour

“…In summary, transformational leadership promotes employees' positive behaviors. These include helping co-workers, participating in organizational activities, and actively taking on tasks outside their specific job definition, as well as developing new suggestions and creative ideas; in other words, bettering their performance (Asif et al, 2019;Calia et al, 2021;Maheshwari, 2021).…”

Assessing the Impacts of COVID-19 on Women Refugees in South Africa

“…Aware of the ethical challenges of data collection with vulnerable populations, particularly during the COVID-19 pandemic ( Calia et al 2021 ), we employed a feminist approach to ensure that the research was carried out in a fully gender-responsive and ethical manner ( Singh et al 2021 ). By a feminist approach we understand a research approach which is concerned with tackling unequal power hierarchies based on gender, race, class, etc., and on revealing aspects of the world that are ‘unavailable from dominant perspectives’ ( Crenshaw 1991 ).…”

Untitled

“…Während Refugee Studies an sich schon ein spezifisches methodisches Instrumentarium und sensible Zugänge erfordern, sind in dieser Krise zusätzliche ethische Fragen evident (Calia et al 2020). Mehrere der angeführten Forschungen sind Panelstudien, die auf quantitative Daten oder alternativen Zugänge, wie z.B.…”