Ethical erosion in newly qualified doctors: perceptions of empathy decline

Abstract

ObjectivesThis study sought to understand whether UK Foundation doctors perceived the phenomena of ethical erosion and empathy decline during their initial period of clinical practice, and if so, why this occurred. MethodsThis qualitative study used semi-structured interviews with nine doctors in their first year of clinical practice at Royal Bolton Hospital, UK. Participants were invited to discuss the definition of empathy, how individuals acquire and maintain empathic ability, perceptions of ethical erosion in the self and others, and how clinical experiences have influenced their empathic ability. The interviews were transcribed, and analysed to identify emergent themes. ResultsEach participant reported a conscious acknowledgement of empathy decline in their own and their colleagues’ early clinical experiences as doctors. Stressful working environments, the prioritisation of patients’ physical rather than psychological well-being, and the attitudes of senior colleagues were all suggested as possible causes. Some doctors believed that specialties with reduced patient contact had a culture which precluded empathy, and influenced their own practice. In addition, some described how their value judgements of patients had affected their ability to empathise. However, all doctors perceived that empathy skills were desirable in senior clinicians, and some believed that educational interventions may be useful in arresting ethical erosion. ConclusionsNewly qualified doctors are aware of ethical erosion in themselves and their colleagues as they begin clinical practice. This has serious implications for patient care. Improving working conditions may reverse this trend. Empathy skills training within undergraduate and postgraduate curricula may be a useful intervention.

L’influence de l’identité linguistique et de l’âge sur la représentation sociale des services de santé mentale chez les personnes dites dépressives

“…En effet, malgré l'importance accordée à l'approche centrée sur le patient par les établissements médicaux canadiens (Frank, Snell et Sherbino, 2015), l'application de cette approche ne peut être garantie en contexte professionnel. Plutôt, nous sommes forcés de constater l'existence durable d'un manque perçu de compréhension chez plusieurs professionnels de la santé, souvent suscité par des contraintes de temps, une érosion personnelle de l'empathie ou même une condescendance indue (Hojat, 2016 ;Stratta, Riding et Baker, 2016). Cet élément est un facteur explicatif important du stigma et du jugement ressentis par les participants à notre étude ; il a d'ailleurs été explicitement verbalisé lors des entrevues.…”

Integrating humanities curricula in medical education: a needs assessment

“…Effective humanities teaching also includes time for reflection and focused mentoring to ensure positive learning experiences are gained (Stern 2008). The human connection engendered in humanities interventions may help preserve empathy felt towards patients, which has been identified previously as an area of importance (Pedersen 2010, Stratta 2016.…”

The ‘values journey’ of nursing and midwifery students selected using multiple mini interviews; Year One findings

“…Such erosion is more recently described and attributed to the effect of work environments and collegial attitudes by Jack (2017). An increase in cynicism and decrease in idealism is a recognized part of students' journey through medical school (Drybe, Thomas, & Shanafelt, 2005;Feudtner, Christakis, & Christakis, 1994;Hafferty, 1991;Stratta, Riding, & Baker, 2016). The authors conceptualise this 'movement' as a 'values journey' through which healthcare students might travel during their career progression.…”