Ethnic Minority Students’ Career Expectations in Prospective Professions: Navigating between Ambitions and Discrimination

Abstract

This study sheds light on how ethnic minority students in Norway seek to navigate occupational opportunities after graduating from professional bachelor programmes. Students' career ambitions and career expectations are investigated. The study adopts a comparative approach and includes students of Asian origin, Western minority students as well as majority students. The findings show that ethnic minorities have higher career ambitions than majority students, but their career expectations are not correspondingly high. The study identifies ethnicity both as a resource (ethnic capital) and as an obstacle in the pursuit of a professional career. Structural disadvantages such as perceived discrimination seem to curb the utility of ethnic capital in capitalising on occupational opportunities, particularly for managerial positions. Ethnicity as a resource seems to play a role among both Asian and Western minority students, and appears particularly strong in the development of career ambitions and in the efforts to pursue educational qualifications. KeywordsCareer ambitions / career expectations / ethnicity / ethnic capital / discrimination / minority student / occupational attainment / occupational inclusion / professions / social capital /

Motivation, Migration and Non-standard Employment: A Survey Among Temporary Agency Workers

“…The fact that these typically more vulnerable migrant groups have higher scores along this dimension may reflect the sometimes blurred lines between voluntary and involuntary motivation (de Jong et al 2009). Did the respondents answer that they were motivated by flexibility and variation because they genuinely meant that, or did a positive inclination on these motivational variables rather reflect other career expectations in a segmented labor market (Abrahamsen & Drange 2015)? The 'dual frame of reference' (Waldinger & Lichter 2003, p. 40) may explain somewhat paradoxical attitudes of subordination and optimism in liminal migrant spaces (Henningsen et al 2014).…”

“…Other contributions point to the different expectations of the labor market when mobility stems from necessity rather than choice (Duncan et al 2013;Lusis & Bauder 2010). In a study from Norway, Abrahamsen and Drange (2015) demonstrate that while career ambitions for students with different ethnic backgrounds are similar, career expectations are considerably lower among ethnic minority students. However, Parutis (2014) reminds us that it is important to recognize the dynamic aspects of career expectations for migrants.…”

Etnisk mangfold i akademia

“…I tillegg fortsetter de i utdanningssystemet på tross av at de har lavere sosial bakgrunn (Støren 2005: 90) og lavere karakterer (Støren 2010:31). Studenter med bakgrunn fra asiatiske land uttrykker høye akademiske ambisjoner; da de både har en større forventning om å ta en mastergrad (Abrahamsen & Drange 2015) og et betydelig sterkere ønske om å ta en ph.d. og å jobbe med forskning (Støren 2016: 33). Kunnskapsutvikling på et akademisk nivå må anses som prestisjefylt, og de nevnte studiene viser at også innvandrere verdsetter dette.…”

Karriereforventninger under glasstaket:

“…Med andre ord synes kvinner i alle fall ikke å vaere mindre interesserte i karriere og lønn slik den første forklaringstype (1) hevdet. Resultatene i vår studie er ikke i tråd med den tidligere teoretiske litteraturen (Becker, 1985;Hakim, 2002), men sammenfaller med flere empiriske studier, både norske (Halrynjo & Lyng, 2010;Abrahamsen & Drange, 2015) og amerikanske studier (Rowe & Snizek, 1995;Marini et al, 1996).…”