Ethnic tourism in China: tourism-related (dis)empowerment of Miao villages in Hunan province

Abstract

External tourism development organizations are frequently utilized by the various levels of the Chinese government to develop tourism and boost local economies. However, this often occurs with limited community participation. We explore the role of institutional arrangements in how people within host communities are empowered and disempowered in such situations by looking into the experiences of Fenghuang Ancient Town and two Miao villages in Hunan Province, China. In-depth interviews, participant and non-participant observation, and document analysis were undertaken. Certain community members were empowered by tourism development, especially financially. However, top-down decision-making, local elite systems, cultural habits and responses to these challenges enabled power inequality. This inequality occurred between government, tourism developer and communities, and within the communities. Only through devolution of power can social impacts from tourism development be improved but, even then, local power imbalances may influence the equity of tourism-related outcomes.

Encountering pandas and their valleys in precarious times: A tourism assemblage perspective

“…This paper builds on existing efforts in niche tourism, including animal-based tourism (Bertella, 2014; Margaryan et al, 2022; Ong, 2017; Porter, 2018; Xu et al, 2015), nature-based (Duffy, 2015) and geological tourism (Jutla, 2000) and more broadly, studies in China’s sightseeing (Lian and Yu, 2019; Xu and Li, 2021) and domestic tourism (Liang and Bao, 2015; Ong and Liu, 2022; Tian et al, 2021). Since the new millennium, Chinese domestic tourism has blossomed, bringing forth new products and forms alongside the surge in relevant research in the past 20 years.…”

Study on Protection and Development of County Traditional Villages Group from the Perspective of All-for-one Tourism in the New Period

“…Tongjiang County should continue to strengthen the general survey of the cultural resources of traditional villages, deeply explore the cultural connotation of villages, form unique cultural symbols, and integrate Huaiyu Paper-cut, Bamboo Weaving, Wood Carving, and other traditional skills, Farming Culture, Red Culture into the development and design of tourist souvenirs and traditional craft products, to improve the cultural content and quality of tourist products. By combining the cultural symbols of villages with tourism products, the cultural value of traditional villages can be more reflected, and the influence of traditional village group tourism brands can be improved [27].…”

An Investigation of Rural Spatial Value Co-Creation Using Sociological Field Theory: A Case Study of Xiaozhou Village in Guangzhou

“…Rural tourism research focuses on the trend of shifting tourist attractions toward the needs of community residents, focusing not only on tourists' loyalty to certain destinations, but also highlighting the core concept of humanistic care for the livelihood of rural community residents (Stylidis, Woosnam, & Tasci, 2022). Local governments' use of external capital to promote the development of rural tourism has led to issues such as insufficient tourism empowerment loss of authenticity, lack of development momentum, insufficient participation of diverse entities, and low efficiency of industrial integration (Liu, Chiang, & Ko, 2023;Tian, Stoffelen, & Vanclay, 2021). The abuse of rural resources, both cultural and natural, has also led to the frequent occurrence of value co-destruction, where at least one party's expectations were not met.…”

“…The abuse of rural resources, both cultural and natural, has also led to the frequent occurrence of value co-destruction, where at least one party's expectations were not met. These situations result in a structural imbalance between the supply and demand of tourism products, making it difficult to establish an effective rural value chain and value co-creation opportunities (Tian et al, 2021). Based on sociological field theory and through the observation and investigation of Xiaozhou Village, this paper analyzes the value co-creation mechanisms in different types of field construction, and reveals the impact of value co-creation on rural space production and the village's economic sustainability.…”