Attempts to prepare previously unknown simple and very Lewis acidic [RZn] [Al(OR ) ] salts from ZnR , AlR , and HO-R delivered the ion-like RZn(Al(OR ) ) (R=Me, Et; R =C(CF ) ) with a coordinated counterion, but never the ionic compound. Increasing the steric bulk in RZn to R=CH CMe , CH SiMe , or Cp*, thus attempting to induce ionization, failed and led only to reaction mixtures including anion decomposition. However, ionization of the ion-like EtZn(Al(OR ) ) compound with arenes yielded the [EtZn(arene) ] [Al(OR ) ] salts with arene=toluene, mesitylene, or o-difluorobenzene (o-DFB)/toluene. In contrast to the ion-like EtZn(η -C H )(CHB Cl ), which co-crystallizes with one benzene molecule, the less coordinating nature of the [Al(OR ) ] anion allowed the ionization and preparation of the purely organometallic [EtZn(arene) ] cation. These stable materials have further applications as, for example, initiators of isobutene polymerization. DFT calculations to compare the Lewis acidities of the zinc cations to those of a large number of organometallic cations were performed on the basis of fluoride ion affinity. The complexation energetics of EtZn with arenes and THF was assessed and related to the experiments.