We have purified wild type and exonuclease-deficient four-subunit DNA polymerase ⑀ (Pol ⑀) complex from Saccharomyces cerevisiae and analyzed the fidelity of DNA synthesis by the two enzymes. Wild type Pol ⑀ synthesizes DNA accurately, generating single-base substitutions and deletions at average error rates of <2 ؋ 10 ؊5 and <5 ؋ 10 ؊7 , respectively. Pol ⑀ lacking 3 3 5 exonuclease activity is less accurate to a degree suggesting that wild type Pol ⑀ proofreads at least 92% of base substitution errors and at least 99% of frameshift errors made by the polymerase. Surprisingly the base substitution fidelity of exonuclease-deficient Pol ⑀ is severalfold lower than that of proofreading-deficient forms of other replicative polymerases. Moreover the spectrum of errors shows a feature not seen with other A, B, C, or X family polymerases: a high proportion of transversions resulting from T⅐dTTP, T⅐dCTP, and C⅐dTTP mispairs. This unique error specificity and amino acid sequence alignments suggest that the structure of the polymerase active site of Pol ⑀ differs from those of other B family members. We observed both similarities and differences between the spectrum of substitutions generated by proofreading-deficient Pol ⑀ in vitro and substitutions occurring in vivo in a yeast strain defective in Pol ⑀ proofreading and DNA mismatch repair. We discuss the implications of these findings for the role of Pol ⑀ polymerase activity in DNA replication.Replication of chromosomes in eukaryotes is believed to require three DNA polymerases, Pol ␣, 1 Pol ␦, and Pol ⑀ (for reviews, see Refs. 1-3). Pol ␣ has an associated DNA primase activity and synthesizes short RNA-DNA primers to initiate replication at origins and start Okazaki fragments on the lagging DNA strand. The roles of Pol ␦ and Pol ⑀ in chromosomal replication are not clearly defined. Evidence for essential roles of Pol ␦ and Pol ⑀ in replication comes from genetic studies in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Mutational inactivation of catalytic subunits and some of the additional subunits of both polymerases is lethal. Strains carrying temperature-sensitive mutations in POL3 gene (encoding the catalytic subunit of Pol ␦), POL2, or DPB2 genes (encoding subunits of Pol ⑀) arrest in S phase of the cell cycle with a terminal morphology characteristic of a DNA replication defect upon shift to non-permissive temperature (4 -6). Incorporation of labeled precursors into DNA stops in these mutants at non-permissive temperature (4, 5, 7). The POL3, POL2, and DPB2 genes, as well as the DPB3 gene encoding the third subunit of Pol ⑀, are expressed periodically in the cell cycle with a peak in G 1 to S phase transition (4, 5, 8), which is characteristic of genes encoding DNA replication proteins. Both Pol ␦ and Pol ⑀ have intrinsic 3Ј 3 5Ј exonuclease activities that correct polymerase errors during replication (9, 10). Mutations in POL3 or POL2 inactivating the exonucleases result in a mutator phenotype (11,12).To accommodate roles for Pol ␦ and Pol ⑀ at a replication fork, it was proposed...