The debate about what, whether and when fi scal rules should be reinstated is of existential relevance for the European Union for at least two main reasons. First, the recovery is, or should be, a public good that governments must take care of (Shapiro, 2019). Previous attempts to privatise the burden of recovery have failed and a quick return to austerity entails serious economic, social, environmental, and probably political risks. Second, the European fi scal framework impacts much more than just the size of the budget defi cit. It infl uences defi ning aspects of the social contract, including universal access to healthcare, pensions, inheritance taxes and social mobility, youth employment and the gender divide.As much as economists, as citizens, should contribute to the discussion, the problem is essentially political (Roncaglia, 2015;Di Majo, 2020). But no fair intra-European debate can occur if the fi nancial stability of the euro area is not somewhat secured. This, alas, may amount to a conundrum.