Evaluating Telehealth Adoption and Related Barriers Among Hospitals Located in Rural and Urban Areas

Abstract

To assess telehealth adoption among hospitals located in rural and urban areas, and identify barriers related to enhanced telehealth capabilities in the areas of patient engagement and health information exchange (HIE) capacity with external providers and community partners. Methods:We used the 2018 American Hospital Association (AHA) Annual Survey and IT Supplement Survey. We applied state fixed effects multivariate analyses and Oaxaca decomposition to estimate the variation of outcomes of interest by hospital geographies.Findings: Our research showed substantial differences in telehealth adoption among hospitals located in rural, micropolitan, and metropolitan areas, where adoption rates increase with urbanicity. Rural hospitals were least likely to have telehealth systems with patient engagement capabilities such as the ability to view their health information online and electronically transmit medical information to a third party. They were also the least likely to report that clinical information was available electronically from outside providers. Our model explained 65% of the rural/urban difference in telehealth adoption, 55% of the number of telehealth services adopted, and 43%-49% of the rural/urban difference in telehealth barriers. Conclusion:Findings demonstrated significant barriers to telehealth use among hospitals located in rural and urban areas. For rural hospitals, barriers include lack of HIE capacity among health care providers in the community, and lack of patient engagement capability.

“Can you see my screen?” Addressing Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Telehealth

“…Traditionally, video conferencing technology has been used to provide care for inmates, military personnel, and patients in rural locations. Also, healthcare suppliers, such as Kaiser Permanente and the Department of Veterans Affairs, use telehealth modalities to increase healthcare services and promote better quality of care [ 10 , 11 , 12 •].…”

Telemedicine Lessons Learned During the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…At the beginning of the pandemic, significant financial and employee investments were allocated by hospitals and private practices to quickly accelerate existing telehealth services or create new ones. Not all healthcare systems embraced this shift in focus as hospitals that lacked electronic clinical documentation, were unaffiliated with a hospital system, were investor-owned, or were in a rural area had lower odds of adopting telehealth while non-profit hospitals, affiliated hospitals, major teaching hospitals, and hospitals located in micropolitan areas were more likely to adopt telehealth [3,4]. This discrepancy in access is even more pronounced when looking at a worldwide scale with nearly 3.7 billion people remaining offline [5].…”

Does Telemedicine Reduce health disparities? Longitudinal Evidence during the COVID-19 Pandemic in the US

“…A recent study in 2020 indicates that half of the sample were willing to use videoconferencing visits, and individuals who were older than 65 years (OR, 0.51) or had less education (OR, 0.37) were less likely to express willingness to have a telehealth appointment (10). Previous research shows that it is highly likely to have health disparities in non-metropolitan areas, and rural hospitals were less likely to use telehealth systems, such as checking patients’ health information online (11). Telehealth services are mostly for non-life-threatening health care; thus, there is a variation between the types of diseases in telemedicine.…”