Evaluating the Impact of an Educational Intervention on Documentation of Decision‐making Capacity in an Emergency Medical Services System

Abstract

Objectives: To compare the documentation of decisionmaking capacity by advanced life support (ALS) providers and signature acquisition before, one month after, and one year after an educational intervention. Methods: The intervention comprised a one-and-a-half-hour module on assessment and documentation of decision-making capacity. Ambulance call reports were reviewed for all ALS calls occurring during three two-month periods, and refusals of transport were recorded. Provider compliance with documentation of decision-making capacity and signature acquisition were determined from a convenience sample of 75 reports from each period. Reviewers were blinded to study period. Twenty-percent double data entry was undertaken to evaluate accuracy. Ninety-five percent confidence intervals were calculated to compare frequencies of cancelled calls and documentation. Results: From the emergency medical services database, 7,744 calls before the intervention, 7,444 immediately after, and 7,604 one year later were identified. Documentation rates in the second and third periods did not differ from that prior to the intervention (1.3% vs. 0.0% and 0.0% in subsequent periods), nor did the rates of signature acquisition differ (85.3% vs. 85.3% and 78.6%). The accuracy of data entry was 92.6%. However, the frequency of call refusals decreased significantly after the intervention (from 9.0% to 2.0% and 6.6% in the respective periods). Conclusions: An educational intervention resulted in no change in the rate of decision-making capacity documentation or signature acquisition by ALS providers for refusal of transport. There was a temporary increase in the number of transported patients.

Which extended paramedic skills are making an impact in emergency care and can be related to the UK paramedic system? A systematic review of the literature

“…Skills training described by Riley et al 29 aimed to enhance Canadian paramedics’ documentation of patients’ ability to understand and decide (capacity) to decline ambulance transport showed no effect compared with pretraining records. It is important to ascertain if the 1.5 h of training did not work or was not enough.…”

“…Most studies incorporated a combination of theory and practical training which reflects current UK paramedic training, but a vast range of methods were identified. Even similar methods were not similarly effective; a 90 min case-based discussion did not change practice29 but a 90 min case-based ‘instruction’ resulted in accurate screening but no effect on vaccine rates 25…”

Standard operating procedures as a tool to improve medical documentation in preclinical emergency medicine

“…Having said that, the retention of information by ED staff at ambulance handover is limited, since ED staff tend to focus on their own initial assessment of the patient, which distracts them from listening carefully to the ambulance crew's handover 1 2. Standardised approaches of handover and educational interventions on PCR documentation have been advocated to improve these items of process-related quality of care 3 4…”

Retrospective Analysis of Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Physician Medical Control Calls

“…There is a paucity of existing research on the ability of prehospital providers to perform this assessment. 9,14,15 A further evaluation of OLMD to determine the extent to which these calls involve capacity assessment may aid in future research as well as prehospital curriculum development.…”