Evaluating the motives of child labourers in the informal economy

Abstract

PurposeConventionally, the marginalised population was considered to engage in child labour due to poverty, education or lack of other options, but indeed, a few children work voluntarily. However, a growing number of scholars, in recent years, have drawn their attention to the valuable question, “why children are engaged in child labour in the informal economy”. Even though a few studies have explored the motives of informal workers, to our knowledge not a single paper has explored the motives of child labourers working in the informal economy. The purpose of this study is to fill this gap by evaluating the motives of child labourers, through three competing theorisations of the informal economy.Design/methodology/approachIn this study, face-to-face structured interviews of 45 child labourers were conducted, who worked in different automobile workshops in the city of Lahore, Pakistan. Respondents were selected using the snowball sampling technique as this strategy is suitable for researching sensitive issues and is feasible for small sample sizes.FindingsThe main finding is that no single explanation is universally applicable to all child labourers. Some (27 per cent) justify their participation in the informal sector as driven by necessity (structuralist perspective), majority (40 per cent) explain their participation in the informal economy as a rational economic choice (neo-liberal perspective) and finally, more than a quarter of respondents (31 per cent) engaged in child labour due to their own free will or voluntarily to work for their family (post-structuralist perspective). This study also revealed that entrepreneurial spawning is a key determinant of child labour as the majority of children, in our study, working in automobile workshops intended to start their own workshop business in the future.Research limitations/implicationsThis article shows that children early engaged in work with entrepreneurial intention/spawning. Entrepreneurial education is very important in a child’s life. Entrepreneurial education will be a ticket to fulfill their dreams and learn new things with entrepreneurial attitude.Practical implicationsGovernment should develop the vocational training institutes for children who left the schools.Originality/valueThis study contributes to the body of literature by providing a better understanding of why children work in informal employment, an occupation generally perceived as constituting exploitative working conditions. This study also contributes to the wider literature of entrepreneurship by exploring “entrepreneurial spawning” as one of the major reasons underlying the participation of children in informal work.

Impact of ethical certifications and product involvement on consumers decision to purchase ethical products at price premiums in an emerging market context

“…Studies have shown consumers in developed markets are willing to take a stand against child labour in developing markets Makarem & Jae, 2016). Our research shows that even in a developing market context, where child labour is rampantly used (Ilyas et al, 2020;Kennedy, 2019), the consumers are gaining awareness about the child exploitation 3) is also supported, which means that individuals are more willing to purchase a product that carries both "no animal cruelty" certification and "no child labour" certification. The study shows that consumers have the highest intention to buy the product at a premium price when both the certificates are present.…”

Challenges and opportunities of completing successful projects using Earned Value Management

“…Snowballing allowed me to solicit participants with similarities in qualities that met the criteria of the study. The Snowball sampling technique is convenient for researching sensitive and is feasible for smaller samples (Ilyas et al, 2020). The participants have a project management professional (PMP) Certification, and they are a member of a local chapter of the Project Management Institute (PMI).…”

Legal and Illegal Informal Workers in Pakistan's Sindh Province

“…Limited empirical studies have been conducted to examine the situation of legal and illegal informal workers in Pakistan. Existing literature tends to focus on the overall contribution of the informal economy to Pakistan's economy, rather than providing insights into the specific sectors or regions regarding the working conditions, labor rights, and legal status of informal workers (Ilyas et al, 2020). This creates a research gap in understanding the situation of legal and illegal informal workers in Sindh Province, Pakistan.…”