Evaluating the Quality of Medical Care

Abstract

T his paper is an attempt to describe and evaluate current methods for assessing the quality of medical care and to suggest some directions for further study. It is concerned with methods rather than findings, and with an evaluation of methodology in general, rather than a detailed critique of methods in specific studies. This is not an exhaustive review of the pertinent literature. Certain key studies, of course, have been included. Other papers have been selected only as illustrative examples. Those omitted are not, for that reason, less worthy of note.This paper deals almost exclusively with the evaluation of the medical care process at the level of physician-patient interaction. It excludes, therefore, processes primarily related to the effective delivery of medical care at the community level. Moreover, this paper is not concerned with the administrative aspects of quality control. Many of the studies reviewed here have arisen out of the urgent need to evaluate and control the quality of care in organized programs of medical care. Nevertheless, these studies will be discussed only in terms of their contribution to methods of assessment and not in terms of their broader social goals. The author has remained, by and large, in the familiar territory of care provided by physicians and has avoided incursions into other types of

A Cross-Sectional Assessment of the Quality of Physician Quality Reporting System Measures

“…11 Measures were already designated into these categories by CMS in the 2015 list. For this categorization, structure measures describe the characteristics of the health care facility, such as regulations about the physical plant or certifications, process measures describe the activities done in a health care facility like tests ordered or treatments prescribed, and outcome measure describe the results achieved after receiving treatment from a healthcare facility, such as having high blood pressure controlled to a certain level.…”

Counselling for dementia caregivers—predictors for utilization and expected quality from a family caregiver’s point of view

“…Finally, the individual conclusions were assigned to the three quality categories, 'Structure', 'Process' and 'Quality of results' (Donabedian 1966).…”

Defining high quality health care

“…Efforts by health care organizations to assess, report, and improve health quality are frequently considered in relation to Donabedian's well-established paradigm of structure, process, and outcomes [4], recently reviewed in depth in the context of surgical procedures [5]. Structural measures of quality are typically concrete and relatively easy to measure.…”