Evaluation of Artificial Neural Network to Model Performance Attributes of a Mechanization Unit (Tractor-Chisel Plow) under Different Working Variables

Abstract

The focal objective of the current research is to apply artificial neural network (ANN) and multiple linear regression (MLR) methods for modeling the performance attributes of a mechanization unit (tractor-chisel plow) during the plowing process under both different soil types and working variables. Two different parameters to represent working conditions and soil type were considered as potential input parameters. The first parameter represented soil type by calculating soil texture index as a combination of clay, silt, and sand. The second one was constructed into one dimensionless parameter, namely the field working index. This index linked most working variables such as plowing speed, plow width, soil moisture content, soil bulk density, tractor power, and plowing depth. The performance of the created ANN and MLR models was appraised by computing mean-absolute-error criterion for the testing dataset. The mean absolute error values for draft force, effective field capacity, fuel consumption, drawbar power, overall energy efficiency, rate of plowed soil volume, and loading factor, were 1.44 kN, 0.03 ha/h, 1.17 L/h, 2.28 kW, 0.68%, 73.97 m3/h, and 0.08 (decimal), respectively, when the ANN model was applied. In addition, coefficient of determination (R2) acted as a criterion for judging the performance of the developed models, and their values when ANN was applied were 0.569, 0.384, 0.516, 0.454, 0.486, 0.777, and 0.730 for the same performance attributes, respectively. When the MLR model was applied, the corresponding values of R2 were 0.239, 0.358, 0.352, 0.429, 0.511, 0.482, and 0.422, respectively, for the same attributes. The current study adds to the standing literature by contributing data and information regarding the performance attributes of a tractor-chisel plow unit under specific working variables and soil types. In addition, the models developed for plowing operations in different soil texture and under the field working index are recommended for use in budgeting for diesel consumption, in calculating operation cost, in matching mechanization units of tractor-chisel plows, in estimating energy requirements of tractor-chisel plow combinations, etc.

Modification of Values for the Horizontal Force of Tillage Implements Estimated from the ASABE Form Using an Artificial Neural Network

“…However, to compensate for the shortcomings of using the ASABE model [12], researchers developed and evaluated intelligent computing methods, such as artificial neural network models and fuzzy knowledge-based models, which led to greater progress in the application of many technologies. In addition, these developments provide the possibility to solve complex agricultural engineering problems, particularly the draft force prediction of agricultural implements [30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37]. After entering the relevant parameters for the implement, soil, and working conditions, these intelligent models could provide a straight estimate of the draft force of a tillage implement.…”