Identifying high-risk pediatric patients with non-pharmaceutical poisoning is crucial to avoid prospective complications and decrease the evident hospital economic burden. Although the preventive strategies have been well studied, determining the early predictors for poor outcomes remains limited. Therefore, this study focused on the initial clinical and laboratory parameters as a triage of non-pharmaceutical poisoned children for potential adverse outcomes taking the causative substance effects into account. This retrospective cohort study included pediatric patients admitted to Tanta University Poison Control Center from January 2018 to December 2020. Sociodemographic, toxicological, clinical, and laboratory data were retrieved from the patient’s files. Adverse outcomes were categorized into mortality, complications, and intensive care unit (ICU) admission. Out of enrolled 1,234 pediatric patients, preschool children constituted the highest percentage of the patients investigated (45.06%), with a female predominance (53.2%). The main non-pharmaceutical agents included pesticides (62.6%), corrosives (19%), and hydrocarbons (8.8%), mainly associated with adverse consequences. The significant determinants for adverse outcomes were pulse, respiratory rate, serum bicarbonate (HCO3), Glasgow Coma Scale, O2 saturation, Poisoning Severity Score (PSS), white blood cells (WBCs), and random blood sugar. The cutoffs of serum HCO3 < 17.55 mmol/l, WBCs >8,650 cells/microliter, and PSS > 2 points were the best discriminators for mortality, complications, and ICU admission, respectively. Thus, monitoring these predictors is essential to prioritize and triage pediatric patients who require high-quality care and follow-up, particularly in aluminum phosphide, sulfuric acid, and benzene intoxications.