Evaluation of Four Buffer Solutions for Determining the Lime Requirement for Ohio Soils

Abstract

Lime is used as a soil amendment to achieve the optimum pH suitable for good crop growth. Buffer pH (BpH) measurements have been calibrated to relate the linear drop in pH of the soil-buffer system to the amount of lime needed to neutralize soil to a certain pH level. The amount of lime required to neutralize soil acidity, called the lime requirement (LR), is obtained from soil-limestone (CaCO 3 ) incubations. In this study, 13 soils from Ohio were incubated with CaCO 3 for a period of 1 month to determine the LR to achieve different target pHs. This LR was then regressed with the different BpHs of four buffer solutions [(1) Shoemaker, McLean, and Pratt (SMP), (2) Sikora, (3) Mehlich, and (4) modified Mehlich] to obtain calibration equations. The Sikora and modified Mehlich buffers are variations of the SMP and Mehlich buffers, respectively, but they are designed to promote buffering without use of any hazardous constituents [i.e., chromium(VI) in SMP buffer and barium in the Mehlich buffer]. This study was done to verify the applicability of the buffers that do not contain any hazardous constituents and to calibrate these buffers for predicting lime requirement needs for Ohio soils. Comparing the calibrated equations of the SMP and Sikora buffers with CaCO 3 -incubation LR recommendations revealed that the SMP and Sikora buffer solutions were not significantly different, and a single calibrated equation can be used for these two buffers to determine LR predictions in Ohio. The Mehlich and modified Mehlich calibration equations differed significantly from the SMP calibration equations and were not as highly correlated with CaCO 3 -incubation LR recommendations using a linear model (r 2 , 0.54). Thus, it is possible to use the Mehlich and modified Mehlich for determining lime recommendations, but they require a correction factor such as inclusion of the initial soil pH to improve the precision of the LR prediction. We also found the various buffers tested in this study were better able to predict LR rates for greater LR soils than low LR soils. In conclusion, successful laboratory tests to predict LR for Ohio soils are possible using alternative buffers that do not contain hazardous constituents.

Evaluation of nonhazardous lime requirement estimation methods for Oregon soils

“…Nonhazardous buffer pH methods have been calibrated using lime incubation studies in various regions and have been shown to be effective alternatives to hazardous methods. Based on correlation to incubation lime requirement, the Sikora method was shown to be accurate for estimating lime requirement in Ohio (Viswakumar et al., 2010), Brazil (Santanna et al., 2011), and Missouri (Nathan et al., 2012), with r 2 = .40–.73, .97, and .73–.82 respectively. Similarly, the modified Mehlich method was shown to be an accurate LRE method in Maine (Hoskins & Erich, 2008), Missouri (Nathan et al., 2012), and eastern Washington (McFarland et al., 2020), with r 2 = .91–.96, .82–.89, and .90 respectively.…”