Landfill leachates contain harmful substances viz. chemicals, heavy metals, and pathogens, that pose a threat to human health and the environment. Unattended leachate can also cause ground water contamination, soil pollution and air pollution. This study focuses on management of leachate, by recirculating the rich, nutrient-filled fluid back into the landfills, turning it to a bioreactor, thereby maximising the performance parameters of landfills favourable for electricity production by the waste to energy plants. This study demonstrates a sustainable alternative method for utilising the fluid, rather than treating it using an extremely expensive treatment process. Further, it also experimentally investigates the effect of varying levels of five input parameters of the landfill including waste particle size, waste addition, inorganic content in waste, leachate recirculation rate, and landfill age, each at five levels, on the multiple performance of the landfill using Taguchi’s L25 standard orthogonal array. Experimental results are analysed using an integrated MCDM approach i.e. MEREC-PIV method and statistical techniques such as analysis of mean (ANOM) and analysis of variance (ANOVA). The results indicate that the optimal setting of the input parameters is waste particle size at 9 ppm, waste addition at 80 Ktoe, inorganic content in waste at 2%, leachate recirculation rate at 250 l/day and landfill age at 3 years. Further, inorganic content waste is found to be the most significant parameter for the multiple performance of the landfill. This study presents a novel approach to produce input parameters for power plants which may enhance their profitability and sustainability.