Evaluation of Tu Meke PHO’s Wairua Tangata Programme: a primary mental health initiative for underserved communities

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT: New Zealand’s primary mental health initiatives (PMHIs) have successfully filled a health service gap and shown good outcomes for many presenting with mild to moderate anxiety/depression in primary health care settings. Maori have higher rates of mental health disorders and complexity of social and mental health needs not matched by access to PMHIs. ASSESSMENT OF PROBLEM: The Wairua Tangata Programme (WTP), a Hawkes Bay PMHI, aimed to provide an integrated, flexible, holistic, tikanga Maori–based therapeutic service targeting underserved Maori, Pacific and Quintile 5 populations. External evaluation of the programme provided formative and outcome feedback. RESULTS: The WTP reported high engagement of Maori (particularly women), low non-attendance rates, good improvements in mental health assessment exit scores, strong stakeholder support and service user gratitude. GPs reported willingness to explore mental health issues in this high needs population. Challenges included engaging Pacific peoples and males and recruiting from scarce Maori, Pacific and male therapist workforces. STRATEGIES FOR IMPROVEMENT: Effectively meeting the target population’s complex social and therapeutic needs required considerable programme flexibility, referral back into the programme and assistance with transitioning to other therapeutic or social support services. Referral criteria required adaptation to accommodate some sectors, especially youth. A group programme was developed specifically for males. LESSONS: A holistic PMHI programme delivered with considerable flexibility and a skilled, culturally fluent team working closely with primary care providers can successfully engage and benefit underserved Maori communities with complex social and mental health needs. Successful targeted programmes are integral to reducing mental health disparities. KEYWORDS: Primary health care; mental health; Maori; medically underserved areas; evaluation

Facilitating Access to Effective and Appropriate Care for Youth With Mild to Moderate Mental Health Concerns in New Zealand

“…There is scant literature regarding youth mental health interventions in community settings in New Zealand, with most interventions being adult focused and even fewer interventions demonstrating appropriateness for Māori, Pacific, and lower socioeconomic communities (Abel, Marshall, Riki, & Luscombe, ; Jansen et al., ; Mathieson, Mihaere, Collings, Dowell, & Stanley, ). Additionally, there are few programs based within the community setting that have demonstrated improvements in outcomes for youth populations with mild to moderate mental health concerns (Asarnow et al., ; Felker et al., ).…”

Collaborative mental health services in primary care systems in Latin America: contextualized evaluation needs and opportunities

“…Along with strong support for the development of a comprehensive CMHC evaluation framework in Latin America, there was a clear call for recognition of the multiplicity of existing CMHC systems/approaches and levels of implementation in different jurisdictions. The need for flexibility in performance measurement processes is consistent with existing literature . The inclusion of core and optional evaluation dimensions, as well as a ‘basket’ of performance indicators from which to choose according to each local context, would be an appropriate strategy in this regard.…”

“…The need for flexibility in performance measurement processes is consistent with existing literature. 31,32 The inclusion of core and optional evaluation dimensions, as well as a 'basket' of performance indicators from which to choose according to each local context, would be an appropriate strategy in this regard.…”

Clinical social work in Aotearoa New Zealand: Origins, practice, and future implications

“…There are some services in Aotearoa New Zealand that have developed kaupapa Māori services. These include a CAMHS team (Elder et al, 2009), Māori adaptation of a cognitive behavioural therapy intervention (Mathieson, Mihaere, Collings, Dowell, & Stanley, 2012), and a primary mental health service using the Whare Tapa Whā model (Abel, Marshall, Riki, & Luscombe, 2012). Social workers have been involved in each of these programmes.…”