Evaluation of Virtual Classes Teaching among first-year MBBS students during COVID-19 era in GMC Jammu

Abstract

Background:The Covid-19 era has caused the shifting of medical teaching into an Online podium. This has provided us with an excellent opportunity to recognize MBBS-students' preferences of these Online classes which otherwise did not form a significant part of the traditional medical teaching. We have undertaken online classes for theory & practical for the first time in our medical college at GMC Jammu. So the current study was conducted to assess & analyze the preference of first-year MBBS students between online classes & traditional classroom teaching.Objectives: To evaluate the predilection/inclination of first-year MBBS students between online classes and traditional classroom teaching.Materials & Methods: An institution-based descriptive cross-sectional study was performed on 180 MBBS students of 2020-21 batch at the Department of Physiology in GMC Jammu, after receiving Institutional ethics committee (IEC) clearance who have attended online classes for a minimum of 1 hour per day or 6 hours per week for 1-month duration using zoom or other video-based learning platforms. A pre-structured questionnaire-based feedback study was conducted after obtaining written consent from the first-year MBBS students. We designed a total of 24 questions related to their theory & practical classes, for assessing their preference for Online classes in comparison to traditional classroom teaching with multiple-choice options.Results: In our study, we found that overall, 61.11% of MBBS students prefer traditional classroom teaching over Online classes and 60% of students prefer traditional teaching methods over online learning for practical classes. However, 50% of students reported that accessibility to stable internet was causing difficulty in following Online classes. Moreover, 53.89% of students reported that they get distracted at home during Online classes. Further, 66.11% of students mentioned a lack of personal interaction & lonely experience on the Online platform. Conclusion:In our study, we found that medical students prefer the traditional teaching method to the Online platform for learning as well as examination. For better understanding and learning, the first phase of MBBS students prefers that traditional classroom teaching should be followed by Online classes that can be easily accessed by students at their convenient time. In this study, the majority of medical students reported limited access to stable internet, distractions & disturbances in the domestic environment, & lack of personal interaction as the barriers to Online learning.

Incorporating mobile learning and the CAP(E) framework in improving the receptive skills of students

“…Moreover, there are indications from studies that regardless of integrating information and computer technology (ICT) in classrooms, teachers preferred traditional face-to-face teaching and assessments (Saher et al, 2022). Besides, some authors evaluated online and traditional classrooms and found varying opinions and teachers' preferences for traditionalbased teaching (Shan et al, 2022). However, given these varying positions concerning implementing technology in the classroom, some novel studies insist that incorporating good teaching practices, strategies and frameworks may assist in improving the learning outcomes in a technology-based instructional delivery (Romero-Rodr ıguez et al, 2020a).…”