Evaluative Content Analysis of the Iranian EFL Textbook for Senior High School Second Graders: Vision 2

Abstract

This study sought to evaluate the usefulness and desirability of the English textbooks for Iranian second grade students in senior high school, Vision 2. To this end, the extent to which the textbooks materials satisfy the prescribed curriculum was explored based on Littlejohn's (2011) evaluative framework. Employing stratified random sampling, a total of 12 private and public senior high schools (six girl students and six boy students) were selected randomly among all the schools located in the six education districts in Isfahan. To select the teacher participants, a convenience sampling method was employed and those who agreed to be surveyed took part in the study. The 20 teachers who participated in this study have been teaching Vision 2 since the beginning of 2017 fall. The process of the content analysis deals with a deeply analytical content evaluation based on a framework containing different parts (objective description analysis, subjective analysis, subjective inference) done by a teacher committee. The results revealed that there is a need to adapt the materials to the target situation of use. Such adaptation needs to cover both design-and publication-oriented aspects of the materials. As a practical implication, the findings may urge the developers of the textbooks to launch a modification project relying upon the results of the systematic phase, therefore, it may enrich English teaching and learning material in Iranian high schools.

The Critical Analysis of Hiwar in Madrasah Ibtidaiyyah Textbook based on Core Competencies in the Republic of Indonesia

“…Other studies also reveal that in textbooks, illustrations are needed to support student interests (Mabrurrosi, 2020;Zurqoni et al, 2020), so the situation can make the students interested in the material. Such adaptations need to include design and publication-oriented aspects of the material (Hasanabadi et al, 2021). The theoretical framework consists of a communicative competency model, input and output ideas, and principles for the communicative approach.…”