“Every structure we're taught goes out the window”: General practitioners' experiences of providing help for patients with emotional concerns'

Abstract

Up to 40% of general practitioners (GP) consultations contain an emotional component. General practitioners (GPs) have to provide care with limited time and resources. This qualitative study aimed to explore how GPs care for patients experiencing emotional concerns within the constraints of busy clinical practice. Seven GPs participated in three focus groups. Groups were recorded, transcribed and analysed thematically. Three themes were identified. (a) Collaboratively negotiated diagnosis: How patients' emotional concerns are understood and managed is the result of a negotiation between patient and GP belief models and the availability of treatments including talking therapy. (b) Doctor as drug: Not only is a continuous relationship between GPs and patients therapeutic in its own right, it is also necessary to effectively diagnose and engage patients in treatment as patients may experience stigma regarding emotional concerns. (c) Personal responsibility and institutional pressure: GPs feel personally responsible for supporting patients through their care journey, however, they face barriers due to lack of time and pressure from guidelines. GPs are forced to prioritise high‐risk patients and experience an emotional toll. In conclusion, guidelines focus on diagnosis and a stepped‐care model, however, this assumes diagnosis is relatively straightforward. GPs and patients have different models of psychological distress. This and the experience of stigma mean that establishing rapport is an important step before the GP and patient negotiate openly and develop a shared understanding of the problem. This takes time and emotional resources to do well. Longer consultations, continuity of care and formal supervision for GPs could enable them to better support patients.

Preventing male suicide through a psychosocial intervention that provides psychological support and tackles financial difficulties: a mixed method evaluation

“…The role of the project worker and their ability to create a non-judgemental and trusting relationship was also critical. Previous studies have highlighted the importance of the development of trust and respect in the relationship between professionals and service users, of not feeling judged, and the ability to communicate empathy [ 4 , 34 , 36 , 37 ]. These factors featured strongly in the relationship between Hope Project workers and service users, augmented by direct engagement with advice-giving and/or signposting to appropriate agencies whilst retaining an ongoing relationship with the project worker.…”

Perception of the primary health care response capacity by patients with and without mental health problems, and health professionals: qualitative study

“…Research also suggests that both health professionals and patients with a severe mental disorder have difficulty in communicating effectively about symptoms, drug treatments, side effects, and about how to reach a mutual understanding on the topics of diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment [ 37 ]. Regarding the training in communication skills, a seminal paper published in the Lancet in 1980 highlighted the potential benefit of teaching communication skills in undergraduate medical programs [ 38 ]. Since the time of the study, programs or subjects on communication have been implemented in undergraduate training in health care degrees.…”

Integrated care and the behavioral health primary care provider

“…Most psychiatric care begins in primary care, including prescribing psychotropic medications 5,6,11,12. Patients establish with a PCP and remain with them for years, forming a therapeutic alliance 6,11.…”

“…The concept of a behavioral health PCP is scarce in the literature; however, this idea is encouraging from the lens of integrated care. A behavioral health PCP model may be significant, considering the PCP's rapport with established patients, a robust understanding of the medical model, and experience treating complex patients 5,6. Additional benefits of a behavioral health PCP include complete integration within integrated care, complex referrals to specialists, and reducing nonemergency ED visits 7.…”