Evidence-Based Research in STEM Teacher Education: From Theory to Practice

Abstract

The paper identifies possible causes of STEM education reform failures and suggests how repairing the link between evidence-based education research and teacher education practice may address the problem. The evidence-based STEM education research is described and placed in the STEM teacher education context. The paper shows how this research may help reverse the growing student STEM disengagement, support effective learning environments, bring attention to teacher professional development, and inform STEM education policy. The paper calls on placing research-based STEM teacher education in the center of contemporary reform efforts and conducting evidence-based education research to study the effect of this process on the growth of teacher knowledge and subsequently on student learning. The major claim is that research-based teacher education and professional development are key factors in successful implementation of STEM education reforms. However, more research is needed to examine this assertion. We suggest a four-step approach for incorporating evidence-based education research and teacher education practice as a potential solution: Model-Reflect-Research-Practice. This approach emphasizes teacher-candidates' active engagement with research-based pedagogies as learners and as future teachers. It provides a universal framework for incorporating research-based pedagogies in teacher education as described in the two examples. The first example showcases Peer Instruction supported by PeerWise technology used to promote conceptual understanding through peer learning. The second example focuses on supporting teacher-candidates' growth by asking them to teach short mini-lessons, record and upload them onto the online collaborative platform (Collaborative Learning Annotation System) for peer feedback and reflection. Both examples incorporate collaborative educational technologies to promote the development of teacher-candidates' knowledge for STEM teaching and their growth mindset. The paper emphasizes how making evidence-based STEM education research a foundation of teacher education can help connect education research to teacher education practice and break the vicious circle of STEM education reform failures.

Developing Pre-service Teachers Conceptualization of STEM and STEM Pedagogical Practices

“…It will be difficult for teachers who have never encountered such activities in their learning to introduce them to their classrooms (Quinn and Bell, 2013, p. 26). Teacher knowledge development does not begin or end in teacher education, but it is influenced by it (Milner-Bolotin, 2018). For this purpose, the incorporation of STEM in classrooms requires the preparation of pre-service teachers of STEM education, both for conceptual meaning and for STEM teaching practices.…”

The Effect of STEM-EDP in Professional Learning on Automotive Engineering Competence in Vocational High School

“…The STEM concept is considered capable of improving the quality of vocational education learning (Nadelson & Seifert, 2017). Teachers as learning actors as well as crucial factors in the success of education reform (Milner-Bolotin, 2018). Some researchers recommend STEM to be integrated into quality curriculum development (Margot & Kettler, 2019), increasing student motivation and behavior (Vennix et al 2018).…”

Perspective of Teaching in University Professors: Case Study in A Chilean University

“…This is understood in association with initial teacher training programs because institutions provide knowledge through various courses (often fragmented), while in schools, teachers are expected to integrate everything they have learned into their teaching practice. In this regard, policies on initial teacher training seem to be in line with this other way of conceiving training because the curricular proposals developed seek to break with the previous model of technical rationality, revealing a scheme in which practice is understood as the core component of training (Milner-Bolotin, 2018). In this way, the practice should be included from the initial stages of teacher training programs so that future teachers can be exposed to a situation that requires them to analyze and discuss real situations (Russel, 2018).…”