“…First, examination of the protocols indicates that, whereas dominant group children have revealed ingroup preference from as young as 3 years, some expressed negative affect in their verbal statements toward minority outgroups by 5 years (e.g., Goodman, 1946;Porter, 1971;Radke et al, 1949). For example, Radke et al (1949) Second, although young children were found to express negative affect toward minority group members, race was nevertheless found to be less salient to young children than gender, and typically so until at least 9 or 10 years (Boulton, 1995;Radke et al, 1949), a finding that has also been revealed using a range of other techniques (e.g., Davey, 1983;Fishbein & Imai, 1993;Goldstein, Koopman, & Goldstein, 1979;Stevenson & Stewart, 1958).…”