Evolution of heterophil/lymphocyte ratios in response to ecological and life‐history traits: A comparative analysis across the avian tree of life

Abstract

1. Lymphocytes and heterophils are the two most abundant leucocyte types, which play a major role in adaptive and innate immune defence, respectively. The ratio of heterophils to lymphocytes (H/L ratio) may reflect a readiness to cope with infection through injury (via heterophils) rather than with a communicable disease (via lymphocytes). Since elevated H/L ratio constitutes a corticosterone-mediated response to external stressors, this trait is generally acknowledged as the robust measure of physiological stress in vertebrates. 2. Here, I hypothesized that baseline H/L ratios of birds (as measured under normal physiological function) could be an important evolutionary trait shaped by species' ecology and life history. I predicted that H/L ratios should be determined by traits related to pathogen exposure (migratoriness, sociality, breeding latitude) and trade-offs between investment in reproduction (clutch size) and self-maintenance (longevity). 3. I compiled published data on leucocyte profiles for nearly 250 bird species representing over half of all extant avian orders and nearly 30% of all extant avian families. Phylogenetically informed comparative methods were used to assess evolutionary associations of H/L ratios with ecological and life-history traits across the avian tree of life. 4. Relatively strong phylogenetic signal and phylogenetic autocorrelation in avian H/L ratios indicated that most diversification in this trait occurred relatively early in bird radiation. Fluctuating selection and drift were identified as the major forces responsible for the evolution of H/L ratios in birds, while low H/L ratios were identified as an ancestral state in birds. Finally, phylogenetically informed Bayesian models showed that H/L ratios correlated negatively with longevity and positively with sociality and breeding latitude. 5. This study was the first to describe the patterns of avian H/L ratio evolution in a broad phylogenetic framework. The results indicate that H/L ratios should not be merely recognized as a proxy for the intraspecific variation in physiological stress, but also as an important evolutionary trait, which probably have adaptive significance visible in a wider phylogenetic perspective. | 555 Journal of Animal Ecology MINIAS How to cite this article: Minias P. Evolution of heterophil/ lymphocyte ratios in response to ecological and life-history traits: A comparative analysis across the avian tree of life.

Analysis of the Progeny of Sibling Matings Reveals Regulatory Variation Impacting the Transcriptome of Immune Cells in Commercial Chickens

“…There is published evidence that the heterophil:lymphocyte ratio varies between birds and is highly heritable (Campo and Davila, 2002). It also varies greatly amongst chicken breeds (Bilkova et al, 2017) and avian species (Minias, 2019). We did not observe any corresponding changes in circulating myeloid cells in these birds ( Figure 3 ) so this phenomenon appears specific to the spleen.…”

The impacts of body mass on immune cell concentrations in birds

“…Our second modelling exercise focused on whether lifehistory traits (maximal lifespan, maximal reproductive capacity and the interaction of both terms with body mass) explained more variation in leucocyte concentrations in birds than body mass, after accounting for phylogeny. We expected body mass to explain more variation in all three cell types than either life-history variable, but that phylogeny would also be a strong predictor as observed previously [19,[32][33][34]. We also expected the relative importance of body mass, life-history traits and phylogeny to vary among cell types because of the different defensive functions of each cell type.…”

Large Mammals Have More Powerful Antibacterial Defenses Than Expected from Their Metabolic Rates

“…The weak phylogenetic signal and a small percentage of variation in antibacterial curves explained by phylogeny in general were surprising. Previous analyses of scaling of leucocyte concentrations and in mammals (Downs et al 2020) and birds (Ruhs et al 2020) and leucocyte ratios in birds (Minias 2019) demonstrated that phylogeny explained the majority of interspecific variation.…”