Recent developments in fractional quantum Hall (FQH) physics highlight the importance of studying FQH phases of particles partially occupying energy bands that are not Landau levels. FQH phases in the regime of strong lattice effects, called fractional Chern insulators, provide one setting for such studies. As the strength of lattice effects vanishes, the bands of generic lattice models asymptotically approach Landau levels. In this article, we construct lattice models for single-particle bands that are distinct from Landau levels even in this continuum limit. We describe how the distinction between such bands and Landau levels is quantified by band geometry over the magnetic Brillouin zone and reflected in the electromagnetic response. We analyze the localization-delocalization transition in one such model and compute a localization length exponent of 2.57(3). Moreover, we study interactions projected to these bands and find signatures of bosonic and fermionic Laughlin states. Most pertinently, our models allow us to isolate conditions for optimal band geometry and gain further insight into the stability of FQH phases on lattices.