Examining holistically the experiences of mentors in school‐based programs: A logic analysis

Abstract

The article presents a Logic Analysis of the Scottish MCR ("Motivation, Commitment and Resilience") Pathways school-based mentoring scheme. MCR Pathways provides vulnerable secondary school students with one-toone support, helping them realize their full potential through education. The perceptions of 12 mentors were explored through interviews, thematically analyzed and mapped to derive the program's Theory of Change as regards the volunteers themselves. This model was then assessed against the evidence base yielded from prior studies. The evaluation highlighted a mismatch between mentors' outcome expectations and what they actually gained from the experience. Furthermore, some themes (e.g., being driven by community concerns) turned out to be more prominent in the context of this specific scheme than in the wider literature, as opposed to other ones (e.g., developing friendships). The study generates insights into the ways to attract and retain growing numbers of volunteers, as well as to advance scientific knowledge.

Unlocking the transformative power of mentoring for youth development in communities, schools, and talent domains

“…Qualitative and mix-method research approaches provide a good alternative for quality assurance and for researchers and program staff to understand key elements and processes of effective mentoring. Moreover, logic analysis is a type of program theory evaluation to test the validity of the program theory of complex interventions such as mentoring (Bufali et al, 2023).…”