In recent years, the boom of the craft beer industry refocused the biotech interest from ethanol production to diversification of beer aroma profiles. This study analyses the fermentative phenotype of a collection of non-conventional yeasts and examines their role in creating new flavours, particularly through co-fermentation with industrialSaccharomyces cerevisiae. High-throughput solid and liquid media fitness screening compared the ability of eightSaccharomycesand four non-Saccharomycesyeast strains to grow in wort. We determined the volatile profile of these yeast strains and found thatHanseniaspora vineaedisplayed a particularly high production of the desirable aroma compounds ethyl acetate and 2-phenethyl acetate. Given thatH. vineaeon its own was a poor fermenter, we carried out mixed wort co-fermentations with aS. cerevisiaebrewing strain at different ratios. The two yeast strains were able to co-exist throughout the experiment, regardless of their initial inoculum, and the increase in the production of the esters observed in theH. vineaemonoculture was maintained, alongside with a high ethanol production. Moreover, different inoculum ratios yielded different aroma profiles: the 50/50S. cerevisiae/H. vineaeratio produced a more balanced profile, while the 10/90 ratio generated stronger floral aromas. Our findings show the potential of using different yeasts and different inoculum combinations to tailor the final aroma, thus offering new possibilities for a broader range of beer flavours and styles.