Examining potential gender bias in automated-job alerts in the Spanish market

Abstract

Numerous field experiments based on the correspondence testing procedure have documented that gender bias influences personnel selection processes. Nowadays, algorithms and job platforms are used for personnel selection processes because of their supposed neutrality, efficiency, and costs savings. However, previous research has shown that algorithms can exhibit and even amplify gender bias. The present research aimed to explore a possible gender bias in automated-job alerts generated in InfoJobs, a popular job platform in Spain. Based on the correspondence testing procedure, we designed eight matched resumes in which we manipulated the gender of the candidate for two different professional sectors (female-dominated vs. male-dominated) and two different levels of age (24 vs. 38). We examined the 3,438 offers received. No significant differences were observed in the automated-job alerts received by female and male candidates as a function of occupation category, salary, and the number of long-term contracts included in the alerts. However, we found significant differences between the female-dominated and the male-dominated sectors in all the mentioned variables. Some limitations and implications of the study are discussed. The data and materials for this research are available at the Open Science Framework, https://osf.io/kptca/.

Gender Bias in Hiring: An Analysis of the Impact of Amazon's Recruiting Algorithm

“…The analysis of this study showed that there is indeed a significant gender bias in job listings, where the use of a large number of gender keywords drives a significant amount of bias, and that the technical bias present in such algorithms has a higher impact and influence on the hiring decisions of female users applying for specific positions. Secondly, as another study mentioned [3], researchers aimed at exploring the automated job alerts generated in InfoJobs, a popular Spanish employment platform. Researchers similarly confirmed the presence of gender bias in such job recruitment platforms and its negative impact on female personnel in the selection process through a corresponding testing procedure.…”

“…To manage the overwhelming number of applicants, Amazon developed an AI-powered automated hiring tool in 2014 that used algorithms to review resumes and select candidates. It may sound like the emergence of this technology has brought well-being to people, based on the popular belief that the machine algorithms used for the worker selection process that have emerged in today's workplaces are more supposedly neutral, efficient, and cost saving compared to humans [3]. However, the Amazon AI-powered automated hiring tool raises gender bias, a very serious ethical problem, which limits the opportunities for women's employment in the Information Technology field.…”

Conversational agents enhance women's contribution in online debates

“…Governments have adapted ICT4D into their policies to empower citizens 43 . Researchers have also conducted feminist science and technology studies to propose ways to empower women's social presence using ICT4D 44 , 45 . For example, some studies show that ICT can contribute to economic well-being and empower women's community building and political organization 46 .…”