The difference in [3 + 2] cycloaddition reactivity between
fac
-[MO
3
(tacn)]
+
(M = Re,
99
Tc; tacn = 1,4,7-triazacyclononane) complexes has been reexamined
with a selection of unsaturated substrates including sodium 4-vinylbenzenesulfonate,
norbornene, 2-butyne, and 2-methyl-3-butyn-2-ol (2MByOH). None of
the substrates was found to react with the Re cation in water at room
temperature, whereas the
99
Tc reagent cleanly yielded the [3 + 2] cycloadducts. Interestingly,
a bis-adduct was obtained as the sole product for 2MByOH, reflecting
the high reactivity of a
99
TcO-enediolato monoadduct. On
the basis of scalar relativistic and nonrelativistic density functional
theory calculations of the reaction pathways, the dramatic difference
in reactivity between the two metals has now been
substantially
attributed to differences in relativistic effects, which are much
larger for the 5d metal. Furthermore, scalar-relativistic Δ
G
values were found to decrease along the series propene
> norbornene > 2-butyne > dimethylketene, indicating major variations
in the thermodynamic driving force as a function of the unsaturated
substrate. The suggestion is made that scalar-relativistic effects,
consisting of greater destabilization of the valence electrons of
the 5d elements compared with those of the 4d elements, be viewed
as a new design principle for novel
99m
Tc/Re radiopharmaceuticals,
as well as more generally in heavy-element coordination chemistry.