The use of fluoride has been increasing because of its great potential for industrial and biological applications. 1,2 However, the World Health Organization (WHO) upper limit of fluoride in drinking water is 7.9 × 10 -5 mol dm -3 , and the high levels of fluoride have caused toxicity in animals and mottled teeth in humans. Several methods, such as ion-selective electrodes (ISE), 3 colorimetry, [4][5][6][7] fluorescence [8][9][10] and capillary electrophoresis, 11 have been reported for the determination of fluoride.Among these, the chemical systems that respond to the presence of ions by color change detectable by vision are rare. 12 These chemosensors do not have any need to use a potentiostat or a spectrometer to detect redox or optical perturbations, and as a result, have substantial advantages over other molecular chemosensors. 13 Lanthanum(III), Zr(IV) and Ce(III) complexes with dye compounds have been used for the colorimetric detection of fluoride.14 These systems have a lack of chemical stability, and take a long time for color development. Supramolecular compounds, such as trianthryl borane derivatives and calix(4)pyrrole derivatives have been examined as fluoride chemosensors via strong hydrogen-bond formation. 5,15 The observed color changes in these systems take place only in organic media, but are reversed upon the addition of water. As a result, procedures for the naked-eye detection of anions in aqueous media are needed to overcome the above shortcomings.A fluoride, because of its high electro negativity, forms stable binary or ternary complexes with many trivalent and tetravalent metal ions, and even with their complexes. It has been reported that Zr-EDTA can bind fluoride as well as oxo anions of arsenic and selenium by a ligand-exchange mechanism with coordinated water. [16][17][18] Hence, the combined use of Zr(H2O)2EDTA as an anion receptor and an appropriate chromophore was expected to give a good chemosensor for the nacked-eye detection of fluoride.In the present study, we observed that PV forms a ternary complex with Zr-EDTA by replacing water molecules, and produces an intense blue color. The blue color of this system readily shifts to orange red by the addition of fluoride, along with the release of free PV.These observations have successfully allowed us to construct a chemosensor for the visual detection of fluoride in aqueous solution.
Experimental
ReagentsAll reagents and solvents used were of analytical reagent grade. A stock solution of fluoride (0.0526 mol dm -3 ) was prepared by dissolving 99.9% NaF (Wako, Japan) in distilled water and standardized using the Alfusone method. 19 Zr(H2O)2EDTA·2H2O was prepared as a white crystal according to the procedure 20 and a 1 × 10 -2 M (M = mol dm -3 ) stock solution was prepared using distilled water. Pyrocatechol Violet was purchased from Dojindo Laboratories, Japan and a 1 × 10 -3 M stock solution was prepared by dissolving an appropriate amount in distilled water. Working solutions, as required, of the above reagents were prepared by app...