Experiences of Silence in Mood Disorders

Abstract

This article challenges the consensus that silences about mental disorders are there to be broken. While silence in mental disorders can be painful, even deadly, the consensus rests on an oversimplified understanding of silence. Drawing upon accounts from depression and bipolar memoirs, this article names and analyses some salient experiences of silence in mood disorders. It does so with two goals in mind. The first is to show that mood disorders may involve several different kinds of lived experiences of silence. This is important because even though silence is considered a promising objective symptom of depression, little has been written about lived experiences of silence in disorders that involve depression. The second is to argue against the fetishisation of breaking silence and the concomitant understandings of silence as an externally imposed and inherently negative phenomenon. This is important because some silences are not experienced as external and are even felt to be valuable, meaning that efforts to break them may be counterproductive.

The Unwillingness‐to‐Communicate: The Study of Adaptation to Turkish, Validity and Reliability

“…Suskunluk, iletişimde anlaşmazlık veya rahatsızlık belirtisi olabilir. İnsanlar, duygusal olarak zorlandıklarında, kızgın veya hayal kırıklığına uğramış olduklarında veya konuşmak yerine düşünmeyi tercih ettiklerinde sessiz kalabilirler (Kacperck, 1997;Hassall vd., 2005;Degerman, 2023). Suskunluğun bazen başkalarını rahatsız ettiği veya iletişim kopukluğuna neden olduğu durumlar da olabilir.…”