“…The multitude of potential metastable hydrated 69 phases complicates prediction of Mg-carbonate formation and thus the stability of the CO 2storing phase (Königsberger et al, 1999;Hopkinson et al, 2008Hopkinson et al, , 2012Hänchen et al, 2008;Montes-Hernandez et al, 2012;Kristova et al, 2014). To reduce some of the ambiguity in the prediction of Mg-carbonate mineral formation under various conditions, in this study we determine the solubility of nesquehonite [MgCO 3 •3H 2 O] and dypingite [Mg 5 (CO 3 ) 4 (OH) 2 •(5 or)8H 2 O], two commonly observed products of carbon mineralization in ultramafic materials (Wilson et al, 2006(Wilson et al, , 2011(Wilson et al, , 2014Boschi et al, 2009;Zhao et al, 2010;Pronost et al, 2011;Schaef et al, 2011;Bea et al, 2012;Loring et al, 2012;Montes-Hernandez et al, 2012;Assima et al, 2012Assima et al, , 2014cHövelmann et al, 2012;Felmy et al, 2012;Beinlich and Austrheim, 2012;Schaef et al, 2013;Harrison et al, 2013aHarrison et al, , 2015Harrison et al, , 2016Harrison et al, , 2017Power et al, 2013aPower et al, , b, c, 2014bKristova et al, 2014;McCutcheon et al, 2016;Chaka et al, 2016;Garcia del Real et al, 2016;Highfield et al, 2016;Gras et al, 2017;McCutcheon et al, 2017), and the transformation process that converts nesquehonite to dypingite. Both nesquehonite and dypingite are readily formed during reaction of Mg-rich minerals with CO 2 at ambient te...…”