“…Several research groups measured γ HNO 3 onto various types of dust particle, from proxy species of dust particles (e.g., α-Al 2 O 3 , SiO 2 , CaCO 3 etc) to authentic Saharan and Gobi dust. However, a large difference in the magnitude of γ HNO 3 onto dust particles has been reported (Johnson et al, 2005;Umann et al, 2005;Harnisch and Crowley, 2001a, b;Underwood et al, 2001a, b;Fenter et al, 1995), as presented in Table 1. Here, the first group of γ HNO 3 has an order of magnitude from 10 -1 to ~10 -2 (Umann et al, 2005;Harnisch and Crowley, 2001a, b;Fenter et al, 1995), compared to a range from ~10 -3 to ~10 -5 for the second group (Johnson et al, 2005;Underwood et al, 2001a, b).…”