In this study, geometrical and theoretical analyses were conducted comparatively for fiber trappings by filaments in the left diagonal, conventional and right diagonal sirofil with right strand and left filament arrangement (denoted as LDS-RS-LF, CS-RS-LF and RDS-RS-LF, respectively)and left diagonal, conventional and right diagonal sirofil with right filament and left strand arrangement (LDS-RF-LS, CS-RF-LS and RDS-RF-LS, respectively). White filaments and blue rovings were used to produce conventional and diagonal sirofil yarns to validate the analysis. Online and offline fiber trapping capacity comparisons indicated that CS-RS-LF and CS-RF-LS had higher capacities of trapping fibers than LDS-RS-LF and RDS-RF-LS, respectively, and lower capacities than RDS-RS-LF and LDS-RF-LS, respectively. Yarn appearance and tensile properties results revealed that diagonal sirofils with improved fiber trappings increased yarn hairiness and tensile properties, while the ones with deteriorated fiber trappings decreased yarn hairiness and tensile properties. Sirofil yarn unevenness CVm decreased as the fiber trapping enhanced by RDS-RS-LF and LDS-RF-LS and increased as the fiber trapping weakened by LDS-RS -LF and RDS-RF-LS. This corresponded well to our theoretical hypotheses on fiber trappings by filaments in conventional and diagonal sirofil systems.