Explaining municipal governance in Kosovo: local agency, credibility and party patronage

Abstract

What can explain the varied e ectiveness of internationally led attempts at statebuilding? This article seeks to answer this question by comparing the contrasting trajectories of governance in two municipalities in Kosovo: Hani i Elezit/Elez Han and Kamenica. In Hani i Elezit, evidence suggests that e ective and accountable governance is embedded. However, in Kamenica informal and clientelist practices persist and residents are less satis ed with the municipality's performance. As the nature and extent of internationally led statebuilding has been similar in both municipalities, explaining variation requires an analytical shift to how local leadership interacts with, receives and ultimately shapes statebuilding processes. The data are based on eldwork from 2012 to 2015. The article focuses on two critical dimensions of statebuilding: capacity building and social accountability. It argues that the impact of externally led statebuilding strategies depends on the orientation of the political leadership of the municipalities. The article identi es features of the political environment, namely credibility and the organization of political parties, which constrain the kind of public-oriented leadership necessary for e ective and accountable governance.