Exploring Adolescents’ Critical Reading of Socioscientific Topics Using Multimodal Texts

Abstract

This qualitative within-individual case design study involved six adolescents (age 10–14 years) engaging in a think-aloud observational protocol to read two texts on climate change from contrasting viewpoints. The participants completed a prior knowledge assessment and survey of technology used to assess potential mediating factors. Survey and observational data are presented as participant profiles. Results illustrated the effect of participants’ background knowledge, emotional elicitation of text features, cognitive dissonance argument analysis due to the contrasting multimodal texts, and impact of visual images on participants’ comprehension. Our data analyses revealed that there is an interconnected and nuanced relationship amongst many text and individual factors when adolescents engage in critical reading of SSI multimodal texts. This research provides direction for future science education research that support learners in critical reading of complex socioscientific topics as presented in multimodal texts with adolescent learners. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10763-022-10280-8.

Mapping and Extending the Theoretical Perspectives of Reading in Science and Mathematics Education Research

“…These preservice teachers were introduced to the metalanguage of referents, processes, time markers, and comparative connectors so that they could gain the language precision to identify the mathematical meanings associated with additive word problems and the inherent language challenges posed by those word problems. Fazio et al (2022) focused on how adolescent learners engage in critical reading of multimodal texts dealing with socio-scientific issues (SSI). Drawing on social semiotics researchers such as Kress (2010) and Danielsson and Selander (2016), they view science reading and literacy as multimodal meaning-making at large.…”

“…Some authors (e.g. Beaudine, 2022;Fazio et al, 2022;Thompson, 2022) explicitly examined this aspect of multimodality in their analysis of reading. Other authors, while predominantly focusing on verbal texts in their analysis, also acknowledged that science and mathematics employ multiple non-verbal resources.…”

Multimodal Texts: Are They Truly Helpful for Narrative Text Comprehension?

“…In the Child Gods story, the teacher used pictures, video, and written language as kinds of multimodal texts. The digital pictures in multimodal texts convey and illustrate information and arouse meaning-making processes (Fazio et al, 2022). Moreover it can boost the students' perspectives using their opinions (Handayani et al, 2020).…”

A Research Paper on Social Media as Educational Interventions for Nurses Professional Development in The Philippines: A Qualitative Study

“…al., 2018). The Multimodal Learning; Critical Consumption theme reflects the diverse learning modalities social media offers, requiring users to critically evaluate and choose content that best suits their learning needs (Fazio et. al., 2022) Interactive Virtual Learning environments are recognized for their potential to foster clinical skills and critical thinking, suggesting that virtual platforms can provide more than just theoretical knowledge (Haleem et.…”