Exploring Patient-Reported Barriers to Advance Care Planning in Family Practice

Abstract

Background: Although patient-centred care has become increasingly important across all medical specialties, when it comes to end of life care, research has shown that treatments ordered are not often concordant with people’s expressed preferences. Patient and family engagement in Advance Care Planning (ACP) in the primary care setting could improve the concordance between patients’ wishes and the healthcare received when patients cannot speak for themselves. The aim of this study was to better understand the barriers faced by older patients regarding talking to their family members and family physicians about ACP. Methods: In this multi-site cross-sectional study, three free text questions regarding reasons patients found it difficult to discuss ACP with their families or their family physicians were part of a self-administered questionnaire about patients’ knowledge of and engagement in ACP. The questionnaire, which included closed ended questions followed by three probing open ended questions, was distributed in 20 family practices across 3 provinces in Canada. The free text responses were analyzed using thematic analysis and form the basis of this paper.Results: 102 participants provided an analyzable response to the survey when asked why they haven’t talked to someone about ACP. 254 answered the question about talking to their physician and 340 answered the question about talking to family members. Eight distinct themes emerged from the free text response analysis: 1. They were too young for ACP; 2. The topic is too emotional; 3. The MD should be responsible for bringing up ACP 4. A fear of negatively impacting the patient-physician relationship; 5. Not enough time in appointments; 6. Concern about family dynamics; 7. It’s not a priority; and 8. A lack of knowledge about ACP.Conclusions: Patients in our sample described many barriers to ACP discussions, including concerns about the effect these discussions may have on relationships with both family members and family physicians, and issues relating to patients’ knowledge and interpretation of the importance, responsibility for, or relevance of ACP itself. Family physicians may be uniquely placed to leverage the longitudinal, person- centred relationship they have with patients to mitigate some of these barriers.

Perceptions of Life Support and Advance Care Planning During the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…However, only about one-inthree US adults have completed an advance directive, owing to multiple barriers for both patients and physicians, including, but not limited to: (1) lack of understanding about ACP; (2) insufficient time during physician appointments to discuss ACP; (3) a belief that ACP does not apply to young or healthy patients; (4) reliance on family or physician-led decision-making over autonomous decision-making; and (5) discomfort with talking about death and dying. [8][9][10][11][12][13][14] Online discussions about ACP may have a significant impact on people's perceptions and behaviors related to ACP. Although the online completion of advance directives has increased nearly fivefold during the COVID-19 pandemic, no prior studies have examined online discussions about ACP during the pandemic in relation to discussions about LSIs.…”