Exploring the challenges in leadership roles experienced by nurse managers in a mining primary healthcare setting in South Africa

Abstract

Background: The challenges in leadership roles hinder the rendering of quality primary healthcare service in the mines. Mining, the heart of the South African economy, requires good health to its personnel to carry out operations. However, nurse managers, the leaders in a mining primary healthcare setting experience difficulties in their leadership roles.Objectives: The aim of this study was to explore and describe the challenges in leadership roles experienced by nurse managers in a mining primary healthcare setting in South Africa.Method: The study was conducted in a mining primary healthcare setting in West Rand, Gauteng province, South Africa. A qualitative, exploratory, descriptive design that is contextual in nature, using a phenomenological approach, was adopted. Data from nurse managers in the mine were collected and data saturation was reached by the seventh participant. The study followed Giorgi’s four stages of the phenomenological descriptive data analysis. An expert independent coder in qualitative research coded the data, and consensus on the findings was reached with the researcher.Results: Three subthemes emerged from the study: mining management and unions interfere with nurse managers’ leadership roles, incongruent mining primary healthcare policies and communication gap between nurse managers and mining management.Conclusion: The triangulation of nurse managers, mining management and unions requires a collective fusion to directly tackle the challenges in leadership roles in mining primary healthcare.

Nurse managers’ experiences regarding the use of key performance indicators in developing work plans

“…Nurse managers often experience a number of challenges in leadership roles that affect the effectiveness of their leadership and the quality of primary PHC services rendered. 18 Similarly, the current study identified four challenges experienced by NMs with the use of KPIs in developing work plans. These included the knowledge of NMs regarding their expected role and function, training and support, resource allocation and exclusion of NMs from selected activities.…”

Determinants and Manifestations of Nurse Managers Emotional Intelligence in Ghana; A qualitative enquiry

“…Nurse managers who manifest emotional intelligence through democratic leadership styles are effective in implementing and maintaining organisational objectives and policies and findings associated well (40). A similar report from a study conducted by (41) indicated that nurse managers being part of most health management teams become conscious of the organisational system, hence their effectiveness in guiding subordinates and implementing organisational policies that help in achieving organisational goals and findings related well.…”

Stretched beyond our capacity: The voices of operational managers from Ekurhuleni clinics during COVID-19

“…Lipsitch and Phil ( 2020 ) annotated that it was more difficult to triage patients in PHC during COVID-19, because a majority of them required a secondary healthcare intervention, and yet the hospitals were also full. Muller ( 2020 ) and Nene ( 2021 ) elicit that the COVID-19 trying times required strong leaders who are resilient, agile and supportive and who can be hands-on to ensure to improve service delivery.…”