Exploring the potential of computer vision analysis of pupae size dimorphism for adaptive sex sorting systems of various vector mosquito species

Abstract

BackgroundSeveral mosquito population suppression strategies based on the rearing and release of sterile males have provided promising results. However, the lack of an efficient male selection method has hampered the expansion of these approaches into large-scale operational programmes. Currently, most of these programmes targeting Aedes mosquitoes rely on sorting methods based on the sexual size dimorphism (SSD) at the pupal stage. The currently available sorting methods have not been developed based on biometric analysis, and there is therefore potential for improvement. We applied an automated pupal size estimator developed by Grupo Tragsa with laboratory samples of Anopheles arabiensis, Aedes albopictus, Ae. polynesiensis, and three strains of Ae. aegypti. The frequency distribution of the pupal size was analyzed. We propose a general model for the analysis of the frequency distribution of mosquito pupae in the context of SSD-sorting methods, which is based on a Gaussian mixture distribution functions, thus making possible the analysis of performance (% males recovery) and purity (% males on the sorted sample).ResultsFor the three Aedes species, the distribution of the pupae size can be modeled by a mixture of two Gaussian distribution functions and the proposed model fitted the experimental data. For a given population, each size threshold is linked to a specific outcome of male recovery. Two dimensionless parameters that measure the suitability for SSD-based sorting of a specific batch of pupae are provided. The optimal sorting results are predicted for the highest values of SSD and lowest values of intra-batch variance. Rearing conditions have a strong influence in the performance of the SSD-sorting methods and non-standard rearing can lead to increase pupae size heterogeneity.ConclusionsSex sorting of pupae based on size dimorphism can be achieved with a high performance (% males recovery) and a reasonably high purity (% males on the sorted sample) for the different Aedes species and strains. The purity and performance of a sex sorting operation in the tested Aedes species are linked parameters whose relation can be modeled. The conclusions of this analysis are applicable to all the existing SSD-sorting methods. The efficiency of the SSD-sorting methods can be improved by reducing the heterogeneity of pupae size within rearing containers. The heterogeneity between batches does not strongly affect the quality of the sex sorting, as long as a specific separation threshold is not pre-set before the sorting process. For new developments, we recommend using adaptive and precise threshold selection methods applied individually to each batch or to a mix of batches. Adaptive and precise thresholds will allow the sex-sorting of mixed batches in operational conditions maintaining the target purity at the cost of a reduction in performance. We also recommend a strategy whereby an acceptable level of purity is pre-selected and remains constant across the different batches of pupae while the performance varies from bat...

Toward implementation of combined incompatible and sterile insect techniques for mosquito control: Optimized chilling conditions for handling Aedes albopictus male adults prior to release

“…However, a modified Fay-Morlan glass pupal sorters can be used to separate Ae . albopictus male and female pupae with a > 99.5% accuracy [ 14 ], and new automatic sex separation systems have been developed and tested to reduce labor and improve sorting efficiency [ 31 ]. Additionally, factors which might influence induced sterility during large-scale mosquito pupae irradiation procedures have been evaluated to further develop irradiation SOPs for achieving sufficient sterility [ 32 ] and reducing negative impacts of male quality so that they can compete successfully for wild females.…”

Aedes aegyptilarval development and pupal production in the FAO/IAEA mass-rearing rack and factors influencing sex sorting efficiency

“…For SIT-based approaches or any other population suppression approach, the elimination of female mosquitoes prior to male releases is not only essential, but mandatory for its application. Due to the lack of a perfect sex sorting method, many sex sorting methods are being used such as metal sieving plates [5,19,34,41], computer vision analysis [48], and the Fay-Morlan glass separator. More consideration should therefore be given to the efficiency of these methods and to factors that could affect the result, so that measures can be taken to avoid the release of females in the field.…”

Advances and challenges in genetic technologies to produce single-sex litters

“…Conversely, however, sgRNAs targeting the haplo-insufficiency genes RpS6 (Ribosomal protein S6) and RpS5a (Ribosomal protein S5a) generated a male-biased offspring sex ratio skew from 93.8% to 56.6%, respectively. This study highlighted that although the X-shredding [74,75], reviewed in [76] Behavioural differences [77,78] Historically, there have been many methods to attempt to produce single-sex litters. We summarise some of the main methods utilised, with the major advantages and disadvantages for each method.…”