Exploring the relationship between reflexivity and reflective practice through lesson study within initial teacher education

Abstract

Abstract:Purpose: A priority for initial teacher education is the development of reflection by pre-service teachers in preparation for transition towards qualified teacher status. Whilst much literature exists on the practice of reflection, little attention has been placed on understanding and developing the processes that inform this practice. Drawing upon the concepts of Strong Structuration Theory, this paper draws attention to the role Lesson Study can play in developing pre-service teachers' processes of reflexivity whilst enhancing their reflective practice.Methodology: Participants were two cohorts of Secondary Physical Education pre-service teachers (n=40), completing a Postgraduate Certificate in Education course (PGCE). Action research methodology was adopted during school placements, when pre-service teacher dyads engaged in cycles of Lesson Study. Data obtained through group discussion boards, questionnaires, group and individual interviews, was subjected to inductive analysis, comparing key patterns to locate themes.Findings: Drawing upon illustrations collated when exploring the enhancement of their reflective practice, the findings illustrate how pre-service teachers (agents-in-focus) were able to pre-reflectively and critically draw upon embodied dispositions and practices to engage with the external structural elements of their training programme. Such interactions enabled them to demonstrate enhanced forms of active agency and knowledge, developing practices beyond traditional support structures of the training programme. Originality and Implications for practice:In drawing upon these illustrations, this paper explores how the application of Strong Structuration Theory further enhances understanding of the underlying reflexive processes that shape pre-service teacher's interaction with the structures of initial teacher education. Furthermore, it draws attention to the part Lesson Study can play in developing creative, confident and reflective pedagogy by pre-service teachers. In doing so this paper contributes to the growing body of literature that illuminates how Lesson Study may enhance the experiences and professional development of preservice teachers.

Designing a graduate entry route for police recruits: lessons from a rapid evidence assessment of other professions

“…Typically, a blended approach which uses both online and face-to-face teaching methods to deliver learning can be effective (Clarke and Abbott, 2008;Hramiak, 2010). Videos can also aid in peer-review (Lamb, 2015;Lamb and Aldous, 2016) and in facilitating more innovative teaching methods, such as video-papers, where literature is interspersed with videos in order to visualise the theory or bring it to life (Krumsvik and Smith, 2009).…”

“…These reflective processes should occur continually throughout education and training, in particular before, during and after practical placements, in order to 'scaffold' or continually build on professional development (Lamb and Aldous, 2016;Coffey, 2014). Traditional police recruit training had incorporated reflective practice to some extent (Vodde, 2008;Rantatalo and Karp, 2016) to allow recruits to consider considering why something was done a certain way, what the possible impact of the action was, and if it could have been done differently.…”

Lesson Study for Professional Development of English Language Teachers: Key Takeaways from International Practices

“…1803-1617 content delivered by external experts. Research on lesson study shows that one of the most empowering influences of lesson study is to help the teachers develop agency in their teaching practice (Cajkler and Wood, 2016b;Lamb and Aldous, 2016). Another prominent result of the prior research is the promotion of reflective teaching practice with lesson study.…”

Lesson Study Partnerships in Initial Teacher Education

“…It was estimated that by 2014 some 10 percent of schools in England had been involved in some form of lesson study, with a prediction that this would double by 2016 (Dudley, 2014c); so, whilst participation in lesson study is growing in England, it is still a very long way from established practice. In a similar way, pre-service teacher participation in lesson study appears to be growing (Lamb & Aldous, 2016), but, with decentralised ITE course provision, decisions to use lesson study reside with individual course leaders, so lesson-study experience is inevitably patchy.…”