Exploring the role of shift work in the self-reported health and wellbeing of long-term and assisted-living professional caregivers in Alberta, Canada

Abstract

Background Numerous studies have found negative outcomes between shift work and physical, emotional, and mental health. Many professional caregivers are required to work shifts outside of the typical 9 am to 5 pm workday. Here, we explore whether shift work affects the health and wellbeing of long-term care (LTC) and assisted-living (AL) professional caregivers. Method The Caring for Professional Caregivers research study was conducted across 39 LTC and AL facilities in Alberta, Canada. Of the 1385 questionnaires distributed, 933 surveys (67.4%) were returned completed. After identifying 49 questions that significantly explained variances in the reported health status of caregivers, we examined whether there was a relationship between these questions and reported health status of caregivers working night shifts. Results We found significant differences between responses from those working different shifts across six of seven domains, including physical health, health conditions, mental/emotional health, quality of life, and health behaviors. In particular, we found that night shift caregivers were more likely to report incidents of poor heath (i.e., they lacked energy, had regular presences of neck and back pain, regular or infrequent incidents of fatigue or low energy, had difficulty falling asleep, and that they never do exercise) and less likely to report incidents of good health (i.e., did not expect their health to improve, were not satisfied with their health, do not have high self-esteem/were happy, were unhappy with their physical appearance, and do not get a good night’s sleep), compared to caregivers working other shifts. Conclusions Our study shows that professional caregivers working the night shift experience poor health status, providing further evidence that night shift workers’ health is at risk. In particular, caregivers reported negative evaluations of their physical, mental/emotional health, lower ratings of their quality of life, and negative responses to questions concerning whether they engage in healthy behaviors. Our findings can support healthcare stakeholders outline future policies that ensure caregivers are adequately supported so that they provide quality care.

Association of 5-item Brief Symptom Rating Scale scores and health status ratings with burnout among healthcare workers

“…Among the work characteristics, longer working hours (more than 46 h/week) for women and night shift jobs for both men and women aged 30 years or above were found to be the most common predictors of high burnout. These findings support the results of a previous study conducted in Taiwan and other countries 13 , 33 – 35 .…”

Individual and organizational features of a favorable work environment in nursing homes: a cross-sectional study

“…However, a positive organizational context may mitigate some of the negative consequences of working the night shift (or evening shifts) to a certain extent [ 32 , 33 ]. There is evidence to suggest that employees working night shifts experience more positive outcomes when they are allowed input, choice and flexibility in their work schedules [ 34 – 37 ]. In addition, Zhang et al [ 33 ] found that sleep quality and duration improved among shift workers (and especially for night-shift workers) in accordance with each beneficial work environment feature introduced.…”

Worker perspectives on the impact of non-standard workdays on worker and family well-being: A qualitative study

“…The lack of exercise among workers with NSWSs may also contribute to obesity risk. Night work has been shown to be associated with less exercise in assisted living caregivers [ 25 ], although not in nurses [ 26 ]. The link between NSWSs and exercise is not fully explored.…”