Exploring the Use of an Online Bilingual Dictionary in EFL Writing

Abstract

The study was an experimental endeavor to explore the use of an online bilingual dictionary in EFL writing by gauging its effect on writing scores, assessing its impact on lexical sophistication, and examining learners’ dictionary lookup behavior during writing. A class of EFL students (n=34) at a Chinese university were asked to write two English compositions, one without access to a dictionary and the other with the help of Bing.dict, one of the most popular online bilingual dictionaries in China. A screen recorder was installed to capture in real time the whole process of dictionary consultation and writing. Results indicate that the use of Bing.dict exerted a significantly negative effect on the overall composition scores and the component scores for content and language use, although it did help to increase the students’ lexical range as measured by the Lexical Frequency Profile. A variety of dictionary-based errors were committed in terms of lexicon, syntax and collocation due to the students’ inadequate dictionary use skills and the unsatisfactory quality of the dictionary for productive language use. A close examination of the screen recordings reveals that the students adopted a range of poor consultation strategies during writing. They were content to find an English equivalent to a Chinese lexical item without bothering to further check its meaning and usage. In addition, they tried in vain to find ready text translations for Chinese sentences or sentence fragments. Focusing on the unreliable web-crawled examples, very few of the students paid attention to the source dictionaries. Besides, most of them were prone to accept what was offered in the dictionary without independent thinking. The findings of the study show a rather disappointing picture of the use of an online bilingual dictionary for language production, suggesting that it is absolutely imperative to train EFL learners on dictionary use.

A Further Look into the Use of a Dictionary APP in EFL Writing: A Replication Study

“…Dictionary use in L2 writing has not received due attention from researchers. As indicated by Chen and Liu (2022), some efforts have been made to investigate how the availability of dictionary impacts on writing performance (e.g. Tall and Hurman 2002, East 2007, Qiao and Wang 2020, Lew 2016, how dictionary consultation affects lexical accuracy and lexical sophistication (e.g.…”

“…A most recent study by Chen and Liu (2022) examined the effect of dictionary use on writing performance, lexical sophistication and the search patterns and strategies of English majors at a Chinese university. In the first week, the students familiarized themselves with Bing.dict, an online bilingual dictionary, and filled in a questionnaire on their dictionary consultation habits, preferences, perceptions on the role of dictionary in EFL writing, and needs for dictionary instruction.…”