Exploring velotopian urban imaginaries: where Le Corbusier meets Constant?

Abstract

Cycling is increasingly seen as a solution to a large variety of urban problems, and as such continues to inspire innovations that aim to upscale cycling to unprecedented levels. Taken to the extreme, these ideas promise a future 'Velotopia' in which cycling constitutes a dominant or single mobility mode. Focusing its attention on Dutch cycling innovations and two recently envisaged cycling utopias by Steven Fleming and Cosmin Popan, the present paper offers a critical exploration of current velotopian urban imaginaries. It does so by tracing their ideological ancestry back to two visionary urban designs of the 20 th century: the dense city of speed and efficiency of Le Corbusier, and the endless Babylon of Constant where mobility is a means of discovery, play and human interaction. Our analysis shows that both Corbusian and Constantian understandings of mobility are reflected in current velotopian imaginaries, not only in opposition but also in combination with each other. This combination of Corbusian and Constantian velotopian imaginaries, we suggest, has largely become part of mainstream urban discourses instead of providing a radical alternative to them.

A Social Sciences and Humanities Research Agenda for Transport and Mobility in Europe: Key Themes and 100 Research Questions

“…The questions cover visions, scenarios, and imaginaries of the future, including fossil-free and alternative mobility cultures, the roles of different trends and technologies, and associated drivers for and barriers to change. As in current research, the desired direction of transitions, novel imaginaries, and the creation of alternative mobility visions, are highlighted (Nikolaeva & Nello-Deakin, 2019;Timms et al, 2014;Hajer & Versteeg, 2019). Scholars prioritise questions on participatory visioning of alternative mobility futures, including slow mobility such as walking and cycling (Sales Oliveira, 2019;Fullagar et al, 2012), shared and smart mobility, and mobility in a degrowth society (Kallis et al, 2012).…”

The diversity of urban street functions and street death

“…Following a similar line of thought as Koolhaas, Le Corbusier held a conviction that urban problems stemming from congestion could be mitigated through the implementation of numerous high-rise buildings accompanied by enhanced density and an efficient transportation system [7]. In his view, streets were to serve a singular purpose: efficient transportation, devoid of any extraneous functions.…”

“…Le Corbusier staunchly believed in the necessity of concentrating on cities, arguing that only through these means could cities truly thrive [7]. His ideal city model eliminated conventional urban elements such as blocks, streets, and inner courtyards, opting for a centralized approach encompassing all functions.…”

A ride on the wild side. Il ruolo della natura nei paesaggi della ciclabilità

“…Aldred (2010), ad esempio, sottolinea come la scelta dell'uso della bicicletta concorra alla costruzione di un senso di 'cittadinanza ciclistica', identificato in base a diverse dimensioni, una delle quali è comunque data dall'essere "responsive to environmental issues" (ivi, p. 39). La centralità della questione ambientale, e indirettamente anche della social nature, all'interno del dibattito legato all'uso e alla promozione della bicicletta è inoltre dimostrata dalle riflessioni, principalmente di matrice sociologica, attorno ai diversi discorsi che presentano la bicicletta in quanto world saver, ossia come soluzione alla crisi ambientale globale, i quali assumono sfumature diverse: da discorsi dai toni mainstream a proposte più alternative e radicali, entro cui alle rivendicazioni ecologiche si affiancano anche critiche sociali e politiche legate alla gestione condivisa delle mobilità e dei luoghi delle stesse (Nikolaeva e Nello-Deakin, 2019;Nello-Deakin, 2019;Popan, 2019;Horton et al, 2016), mettendo in evidenza la natura sociale e politica delle questioni ambientali.…”