How polyphagous herbivores cope with the diversity and unpredictability of plant defenses remains largely unknown at both the genetic and molecular levels. To examine whether generalist counterdefense enzymes are structurally more flexible and functionally more diverse, two counterdefensive allelochemical-metabolizing cytochrome P450 proteins, CYP6B1 from the specialist Papilio polyxenes, feeding on furanocoumarin-containing plants, and CYP6B8 from the generalist Helicoverpa zea, feeding on hundreds of host plant species, are compared structurally and functionally. Molecular modeling indicates that CYP6B8 has more flexible overall folding, a more elastic catalytic pocket, and one more substrate access channel than CYP6B1. Baculovirus-mediated expression of the CYP6B8 and CYP6B1 proteins demonstrates that CYP6B8 metabolizes six biosynthetically diverse plant allelochemicals (xanthotoxin, quercetin, flavone, chlorogenic acid, indole-3-carbinol, and rutin) and three insecticides (diazinon, cypermethrin, and aldrin), whereas CYP6B1 metabolizes only two allelochemicals (xanthotoxin and flavone) and one insecticide (diazinon) of those tested. These results indicate that generalist counterdefense proteins are capable of accepting a more structurally diverse array of compounds compared with specialist counterdefense proteins. T he majority of herbivorous insects are oligophagous, i.e., specialized on a relatively narrow range of host plants (three or fewer plant families) (1, 2). Such specialization is thought to reduce competition for food from other herbivores and to lower predation͞parasitoid risk from generalist enemies (3). Because of the diversification of plant chemical defenses, however, this strategy may compromise a specialist's ability to make use of alternative food sources. A small proportion of insect herbivores, including some of the world's most important agricultural pests, are polyphagous, i.e., feed on a wide range of plant families. Although polyphagous species may have fewer limitations with respect to food availability, the toxicological challenge of generalized feeding is considerable in view of the tremendous diversity of plant defense compounds (allelochemicals). Because these compounds tend to be taxonomically limited in distribution, a polyphagous diet exposes an insect herbivore to a broad and unpredictable array of plant defenses. In fact, biochemical adaptation to a relatively narrow range of plant defense compounds may explain why the majority of herbivorous insects are specialists.How generalists cope with the diversity and unpredictability of plant defenses remains largely unknown at both the genetic and molecular levels. One possibility is that counterdefense genes of generalists have multiple functions; in the case of detoxificative genes such as cytochrome P450 monooxygenases (4), individual proteins from generalists may have a much wider substrate spectrum. Greater functional flexibility could in theory allow generalists to cope with the unpredictability of plant defense (1).Only a f...