Extending Cognitive-Behavioural Theory and Therapy to Medically Unexplained Symptoms and Long-Term Physical Conditions: A Hybrid Transdiagnostic/Problem Specific Approach

Abstract

Medically unexplained symptoms (MUS) are not only common and distressing, but are also typically poorly managed in general medical settings. Those suffering from these problems tend to incur significantly higher health costs than the general population. There are many effective treatments for different MUS; these are almost entirely based on cognitive-behavioural approaches. However, the wide range of treatment protocols tend to be 'syndrome specific'. As such, they do not generalise well in terms of training and application, making them expensive and difficult to disseminate, suggesting the desirability of developing a transdiagnostic approach. The general basis of such a CBT grounded transdiagnostic approach is considered, and the particular need to incorporate cognitive elements of both anxiety or health anxiety (threat) and depression (loss) is highlighted. Key empirically grounded and evidence-based processes (both specific and general) previously identified as underpinning the maintenance of MUS are delineated. The way in which these can be combined in a transdiagnostic model that accounts for most MUS presentations is presented and linked to a formulation-driven transdiagnostic treatment strategy, which is described. However, the need to take more syndrome-specific issues into account in treatment is identified, suggesting that the optimum treatment may be a hybrid transdiagnostic/specific approach with formulation, shared understanding, belief change strategies, and behavioural experiments at its heart. The generalisation of such approaches to psychological problems occurring in the context of 'long-term conditions' is identified as a further important development that is now within reach.

Third-Wave Therapies for Long-Term Neurological Conditions: A Systematic Review to Evaluate the Status and Quality of Evidence

“…An up-to-date review by Salkovskis et al (2016) has discussed the utility of a CBT-grounded transdiagnostic approach to working therapeutically with long-term conditions generally. The paper highlights transdiagnostic factors important to consider including mood changes, attentional processes, emotional avoidance/suppression, safety-seeking behaviours, all-or-nothing (boom or bust) behaviour, generalised withdrawal, rumination, autonomic arousal, sleep disturbances and the potential for deconditioning in some diagnoses.…”

Investigating the role of beliefs about emotions, emotional suppression and distress within a pain management programme for fibromyalgia

“…2,3 Biopsychosocial explanations, however, in addition to accounting for neurobiological triggers, acknowledge the important role of cognitions, behaviour and social interactions in maintaining symptoms of fibromyalgia. 4,5 A recent systematic review explored the role of emotion regulation in chronic pain and its relation to outcomes across 15 studies. 6 Emotion regulation strategies were described as either antecedent-focused (i.e.…”

“…2,3 Biopsychosocial explanations, however, in addition to accounting for neurobiological triggers, acknowledge the important role of cognitions, behaviour and social interactions in maintaining symptoms of fibromyalgia. 4,5…”

Fatigue interventions in long term, physical health conditions: A scoping review of systematic reviews

“…Recently there has been a move towards conceptualising fatigue as having commonalities across conditions and identifying person-specific (rather than solely illness-specific) factors across domains (i.e. behavioural, cognitive, physiological, social and emotional) [ 8 , 9 ] in a more transdiagnostic approach to management.…”