Total pancreatectomy with islet autotransplantation (TPIAT) was first performed at the University of Minnesota in 1977 and has significantly improved options for the treatment of chronic pancreatitis, especially in patients with small duct disease. 1 Total pancreatectomy alone in chronic pancreatitis results in significant improvement in pain but is associated with brittle diabetes mellitus. This problem is significantly ameliorated with autotransplantation of islets isolated from the patient's pancreas using enzymatic techniques. Thus, TPIAT allows for complete surgical removal of the diseased pancreas with reduced consequences of loss of islet cell mass. The experience with TPIAT has grown at the University of Minnesota, and TPIAT has been performed in more than 500 cases since 1977. Interim experience with 409 patients was published in 2012, 2 with results demonstrating significant durable relief of pain and excellent diabetes control with improved quality of life. Our experience suggests that TPIAT is a very beneficial procedure with excellent outcomes if performed in an appropriate patient population. Given the difficulty in early diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis and heterogeneity of the population of patients with chronic pancreatitis, defining the appropriate population is sometimes difficult, leading us to develop clear, protocol-driven application of TPIAT. We strongly believe that all patients with chronic pancreatitis, who are being considered for TPIAT, benefit from discussion in a multidisciplinary forum consisting of surgeons, gastroenterologists, pain specialist, clinical psychologist, and endocrinologists and only patients who strictly meet the criteria for surgery should be considered for this procedure (Table 1). 3 Pancreatic malignancy or concern for malignancy remains a clear exclusion criterion at our center. Patients with malignancy involving the gland or diffuse intrapancreatic mucinous neoplasm are not considered for TPIAT. To date, we are unaware of disseminated pancreatic malignancy developing in any of the more than 500 patients in our robust experience. However, the concern regarding inadvertent infusion of malignant ductal cells is real, given that the isolation process enriches islets but does not totally eliminate ductal cells. The content of ductal cells (the hypothesized cell of origin for pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma) in the islet preparation varies but is still significant even under the best isolation conditions. 4 Multifocality has been described in pancreatic cancer. 5,6 Furthermore, a field defect phenomenon is certainly a part of the disease process in intrapancreatic mucinous neoplasm. Although pancreatic cancer recurs most commonly as distant metastasis, it recurs solely in the pancreatic resection bed in about a quarter of patients. 7 These tumors are either new primaries or local recurrences (suggesting that even negative margins cannot predict removal of all disease), both of which create a concern for the use of islet preparation contaminated with ductal cells in...