External Merge Sort for Top-K Queries

Abstract

Business intelligence and web log analysis workloads often use queries with top-k clauses to produce the most relevant results. Values of k range from small to rather large and sometimes the requested output exceeds the capacity of the available main memory. When the requested output fits in the available memory existing top-k algorithms are efficient, as they can eliminate almost all but the top k results before sorting them. When the requested output exceeds the main memory capacity, existing algorithms externally sort the entire input, which can be very expensive. Furthermore, the drastic difference in execution cost when the memory capacity is exceeded results in an unpleasant user experience. Every day, tens of thousands of production top-k queries executed on F1 Query resort to an external sort of the input. To address these challenges, we introduce a new top-k algorithm that is able to eliminate parts of the input before sorting or writing them to secondary storage, regardless of whether the requested output fits in the available memory. To achieve this, at execution time our algorithm creates a concise model of the input using histograms. The proposed algorithm is implemented as part of F1 Query and is used in production, where significantly accelerates top-k queries with outputs larger than the available memory. We evaluate our algorithm against existing top-k algorithms and show that it reduces I/O traffic and can be up to 11× faster. * Work done while at Google Inc.