Eccrine poroma (EP) is a benign adnexal tumor that is derived from acrosyringium, the intraepidermal eccrine duct of sweat glands. The standard treatment for eccrine poroma is complete excision. However, this case report highlights cryotherapy as one of the modalities in treating eccrine poroma. We present a case of a 33-year-old male patient who was a known case of generalized vitiligo since he was nine years old. During our skin checkup before starting him on phototherapy, we found a mass over the palmar aspect of the middle finger of the right hand that started to appear five years ago. The mass gradually increased in size, was painless, has no discharge, and was not associated with a history of trauma or infection. The review of systems was unremarkable. Skin examination revealed an asymptomatic, 2.0 × 1.5 cm-sized, solitary, collarette-encircled, dome-shaped, flesh-colored, non-pigmented, deep-red nodule protrusion from the palmar aspect of the middle finger of the right hand. Poroma was considered as the diagnosis, and a punch skin biopsy was performed to confirm the diagnosis and to roll out pyogenic granuloma, amelanotic melanoma, and porocarcinoma as differential diagnoses. A 3 mm punch skin biopsy was performed under local anesthesia and was found to be histologically consistent with eccrine poroma. Hence, cryosurgery was chosen based on histological favorable features. We used cryospray in a single session of 15 seconds in three applications, with five-second intervals in between (skin frosting recovery). Furthermore, the lesion was completely curative with a single session of cryotherapy. The patient followed up for one year without evidence of recurrence.