Factors influencing effectiveness in postgraduate medical education – a qualitative study of experiences of the responsible clinical consultants

Abstract

BackgroundMedical education leaders are important for educational quality in postgraduate medical education. Their work tasks are complex and contain different components. However, factors that are influencing leaders´ effectiveness in completing these tasks are unexplored. Understanding and developing these factors is most likely essential to strengthen postgraduate medical education and to consequently improve the quality in health care delivery. This study explores the experiences of factors that influence effectiveness of clinical consultants responsible for postgraduate medical education at clinical departments. Effectiveness was defined as fulfillment of work tasks.MethodsA qualitative study was performed with data gathered through semi-structured face-to-face interviews with 17 consultants responsible for postgraduate medical education. Data was analyzed by qualitative content analysis.ResultsFindings clustered into four themes of factors influencing effectiveness: individual (being an expert, social competence), relational (support and cooperation, communication), attitudinal (shared vision, organizational values, colleagues’ attitudes) and structural (organizational characteristics, regulations and guidelines, conditions for the role). The factors were experienced to influence effectiveness in a positive or a negative direction.ConclusionsThis study shed light on the complex and interrelated factors experienced to have impact on the role of consultant responsible for postgraduate medical education. Viewing the result through the concept of power, the role mainly relies on personal power sources like expert and referent power whereas power connected to the position often are lacking. To increase effectiveness of the role, a differentiated strategy which involves activities at both individual, group and organizational levels is needed.

The state of infectious disease training in Germany before introduction of the new board certification in internal medicine and infectious diseases: past experience and future expectations

“…In conjunction with the available data, this shows that interest and possible training paths in the discipline should already be promoted at the university level. Therefore, efforts should be made to improve the visibility and accessibility of relevant training opportunities, especially for students who are interested in pursuing a career in infectious diseases [ 6 ]. Residents were probably more likely to be informed about the planned cancellation of the DGI’s ID specialist [ 7 ].…”

“…Many of the specialists already decided to train in ID during their studies (31.4%) or during their further training as specialists (34.8%), so that it is clear here that junior staff should be recruited at the early stages of the professional career. Obviously, investment in exciting and dedicated ID education should be seen as an investment into the promotion of new talent in order to attract new physicians to the field of ID [ 6 , 12 ].…”

Evaluation of Adaptive Feedback in a Smartphone-Based Game on Health Care Providers’ Learning Gain: Randomized Controlled Trial

“…Study variables used in this analysis were study groups, exposure to previous neonatal training, clinical cadre, age, and level of experience. This was because given the differences in training pathways for clinical cadres and length of practice, level of expertise might produce differences in the effectiveness of the learning intervention [ 59 ]. In addition, age was included to evaluate whether it was associated with the pattern and effectiveness of smartphone-based learning given its novel nature requiring digital acuity [ 60 ].…”