Factors Influencing the Choice between Road and Multimodal Transportation

Abstract

on-sustainable transportation is a great part of the stress that human activities put on the environment. Road transportation constituted 74% of the total inland tonne-kilometres in the EU during 2009, to be compared to rail transportation at 15%. In Sweden the numbers are slightly more in favour of rail transportation, but still a small share despite the fact that the European Committee promotes sustainable modes of transport. To reduce the environmental impact from the transport sector, and be able to promote the use of sustainable transport modes, it is important to gain an understanding of why the modal balance is disposed this way. By case studies and a survey, four factors, viz costs, environmental impact, attitudes and risks, and their impact on the choice of mode of transportation for companies located in the vicinity of a rail terminal are studied.The results clearly show that the environmental impact of rail transportation is only a fraction of that of the road transportation and could possibly influence the choice of rail transportation in a positive way. However, rail transportation is less cost efficient, flexible and reliable and these aspects -despite the advantageous conditions in terms of infrastructure and geographical vicinity to a rail terminalcontribute to a negative bias towards rail transportation among companies in the study. Thus, the cost and attitudes factors counteract the choice of rail transportation. In addition, risks, as the final factor, also counteracts the choice, since it is found that respondents consider the risks of disturbances such as delays, theft and accidents to be important when considering mode of transportation and that rail transportation is viewed as lacking compared to road transportation.This thesis contributes to the existing theory about the costs-related issues and the environmental impact of rail transportation, as well as how companies with beneficial conditions to employ rail transportation consider the mode with regards to e.g. reliability and safety, and how these factors influence the modal choice among buyers of transportation services that are located close to a rail terminal. With this knowledge, policymakers are informed of which areas to concentrate taxes, subsidizations and information to. These things are in all probability necessary if a large scale modal shift is desired. The contribution of the effect a modal shift could have on the environmental impact of the transportation might make certain practitioners that compete on a market where a low environmental footprint is a strong competitive weapon to rethink their modal choice. N iii ivPopulärvetenskaplig sammanfattning et är lätt att föreställa sig en renare värld. En värld där ingen hostar på grund av avgaser, där sot inte täcker husväggar eller förmörkar himlen. En värld där gräset är grönare och där vackra, snötyngda vinterskogar inte är en syn hotad av ett varmare klimat. Det är inte alls lika lätt att tänka sig en värld utan lastbilarstransporter. Men att minska antalet lastbil...

The effectiveness of EC policies to move freight from road to rail: Evidence from CEE grain markets

“…This large body of literature consistently laments the failure of rail freight to meet the market share expectations presented in the EC papers; currently the average market share of rail freight in EU-28 sits in the 11-12 percent range of ton-kilometres (European Commission, 2019c), and many specialists expect it to fall rather than rise in the near future as motor carrier productivity and capabilities continue to improve. 9 Another frequent point is the call for government policies directly supporting rail carriage as a modal choice vis-a-vis motor carriage for freight (for example, Helgedal, 2013;Arencibia, et al, 2015).…”

Factors Influencing Spot and Forward Freight Rates in Indian Logistics Industry

“…The key affecting factors are transportation reliability, timely delivery and freight tariffs. [4] identified various factors like Flexibility ,Delivery speed, delivery precision, Environmental issues ,Costs related choice of mode of transportation ,Reliability are the most influencing. [14] The key factors that affect costs include distance, waiting time, delivery time, fuel price, cargo value -to-weight, the direction of freight routes, and load factors.…”

Comparison of External Costs in Multimodal Container Transport Chain

“…The road transportation included in multimodal transport chain shares in the external costs in a greater to a lesser degree. Environmental impacts of multimodal transport are lower than in road transportation which carries the negative social cost and perception [13]. There are efforts in EU transport policy to redirect road transport into a more acceptable transport mode [14].…”